Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0905.1467 · European Journal of Physics

Classical behaviour in quantum systems: the case of straight tracks in a cloud chamber

Alessandro Teta

Published Dec 15, 2009• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The aim of this paper is to discuss in a pedagogical way the problem of the emergence of classical behaviour in certain physical systems which, in principle, are correctly described by quantum mechanics. It is stressed that the limit ℏ → 0 is not sufficient and the crucial role played by the environment must be taken into account. In particular, recalled is the old problem raised by Mott in 1929 ( Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 126 79) concerning the straight tracks observed in a cloud chamber, produced by an α-particle emitted by a source in the form of a spherical wave. The conceptual relevance of the problem for a clearer understanding of the classical limit is discussed in a historical perspective. Moreover, a simple mathematical model is proposed, where the result of Mott is obtained in a rigorous mathematical way.

DOI
10.1088/0143-0807/31/1/019

Related papers

From quantum to classical world: emergence of trajectories in a quantum system

Rodolfo Figari, Alessandro Teta

This note deals with models of quantum systems where the emergence of a classical behavior can be concretely analyzed. We first briefly review some well known difficulties arising in the classical limit of quantum mechanics according to the Copenhagen interpretation. Then we discuss the seminal contribution by Mott (1929) on the tracks observed in a cloud chamber, where the problem can be approached in a particularly transparent way. Finally, we propose a model Hamiltonian, with interaction described by spin dependent point interactions, where Mott’s analysis can be rephrased and the result can be rigorously formulated.

Mathematics and Mechanics of Complex Systems•Dec 17, 2016•3 citations

Physical origins and limitations of canonical quantum measurement behavior

Jonathan Schonfeld

I review and augment my work of the last few years on the physical origins and limitations of canonical quantum measurement behavior. Central to this work is a detailed analysis of the microstructure of real measurement devices. Particular attention is paid to the Mott problem, which addresses a simpler version of canonical quantum measurement behavior: It asks why an Alpha particle emitted in nuclear decay produces one and only one track in a cloud chamber. My analysis - entirely consistent with unitarity - leads to an emergent, approximate Born rule supported by experiment, with possible breakdown at very small probability density. I argue that a similar picture applies to other measurement scenarios, including Geiger counters, the Stern-Gerlach experiment and superconducting qubits.

arXiv:2505.00716•Kragujevac Journal of Science•Jan 1, 2025•2 citations

The classical limit

Peter Holland

Conceptual and formal problems Many of the problems surrounding the interpretation of quantum mechanics stem from the absence of a sufficiently general and physically transparent analysis of the connection with the domain in which classical concepts are assumed to apply. It is the purpose of this chapter to describe with the aid of a few examples how the quantum potential approach provides a context within which the conceptual and formal issues raised by this problem may be clarified. A key question is to explain how the state or context dependence which is so characteristic of the quantum domain turns into state independence at a certain level, characterized as ‘classical’. To illustrate one aspect of the conceptual problem we recall that in Bohr's interpretation the validity of classical concepts is already presupposed since, it is suggested, it is only in terms of these that one can unambiguously communicate the results of experiments in the quantum domain. Thus, classical physics must be considered as prior to quantum mechanics and the latter is a generalization of the former in that it provides a new set of laws governing the application of classical concepts. According to this view, any procedure by which classical mechanics is recovered from quantum mechanics as a mathematical limit can only be a demonstration of consistency with the already postulated epistemological relation between the two theories and not as a ‘derivation’ of classical mechanics from quantum mechanics (George, Prigogine & Rosenfeld, 1972).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 13, 1993•0 citations

A Top-down View of the Classical Limit of Quantum Mechanics

Sebastián Fortín, Olímpia Lombardi

At present there is a consensus about the fact that the emergence of the classical world from the underlying quantum reality involves the physical phenomenon of decoherence, which is usually studied in the version proposed by Zurek and his collaborators. According to this version, decoherence is a process resulting from the interaction between a quantum system and its environment (environment-induced decoherence, EID); this process singles out the observables that receive definite classical values. The aim of this paper is to propose a top-down approach to decoherence, which takes the perspective of the whole closed system, and considers whether each set of degrees of freedom decoheres or not. This approach is more general than the orthodox open-system perspective and dissolves some of its conceptual problems. Although decoherence becomes relative to the way in which the closed system is decomposed, the quantum-to-classical transition defines unequivocally the realm of classicality by identifying the observables with classical-like behavior.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC (EUROPE) eBooks•Nov 14, 2016•11 citations

The Mott Problem Revisited: Collapse Geometry, Resonant Measurement, and Trajectory Formation

Young, Charles

The Mott problem concerns a long-standing paradox in quantum mechanics: although alpha-particle wavefunctions emitted from radioactive sources are spherically symmetric, cloud chambers consistently record straight-line tracks. Standard explanations rely on decoherence, probabilistic branching, or implicit classical assumptions, yet none fully resolve how directional trajectories emerge from an initially isotropic quantum state. This paper presents a geometric interpretation of the Mott problem within the Dimensional Evolution (DE) framework, in which wavefunction collapse is treated as a resonance- and identity-mediated geometric process rather than a purely probabilistic event. Measurement is modeled as a structured interaction between system and detector identity wells, producing directional collapse funnels that anchor sequential localization events. Trajectory formation is described as a process of coherent tether crystallization, whereby successive measurement interactions align collapse curvature along a stable resonant direction. Straight tracks arise not from classical particle paths, but from the geometric reinforcement of collapse orientation through detector–system coupling. Inverse-domain resonance matching replaces environment-driven decoherence as the primary mechanism governing localization. The DE approach resolves the Mott paradox without invoking hidden variables, many-worlds branching, or ad hoc classical transitions, and provides a unified geometric explanation for trajectory emergence in quantum measurement systems. Implications for quantum foundations, measurement theory, and experimental testability are discussed.

•Dec 16, 2025•0 citations

The wave mechanics of ∝-Ray tracks

Nevill Francis Mott

Abstract The present note is suggested by a recent paper by Prof. Darwin,* and is intended to show how one of the most typically particle-like properties of matter can be derived from the wave mechanics. In the theory of radioactive disintegration, as presented by Gamow, the ∝-particle is represented by a spherical wave which slowly leaks out of the nucleus. On the other hand, the ∝-particle, once emerged, has particle-like properties, the most striking being the ray tracks that it forms in a Wilson cloud chamber. It is a little difficult to picture how it is that an outgoing spherical wave can produce a straight track ; we think intuitively that it should ionise atoms at random throughout space. We could consider that Gamow’s outgoing spherical wave should give the probability of disintegration, but that, when the particle is outside the nucleus, it should be represented by a wave packet moving in a definite direction, so as to produce a straight track. But it ought not to be necessary to do this. The wave mechanics unaided ought to be able to predict the possible results of any observation that we could make on a system, without invoking, until the moment at which the observation is made, the classical particle-like properties of the electrons or α-particles forming that system. If we consider the ∝-ray alone as the system under consideration, then the gas of the Wilson chamber must be considered as the means by which we observe the particle ; so in this case we must consider the ∝-ray as α-particle as soon as it is outside the nucleus, because that is the moment at which the observation is made. If, however, we consider the α-particle and the gas together as one system, then it is ionised atoms that we observe ; interpreting the wave function should give us simply the probability that such and such an atom is ionised. Until this final interpretation is made, no mention should be made of the ∝-ray being a particle at all. The difficulty that we have in picturing how it is that a spherical wave can produce a straight track arises from our tendency to picture the wave as existing in ordinary three dimensional space, whereas we are really dealing with wave functions in the multispace formed by the co-ordinates both of the α-particle and of every atom in the Wilson chamber.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character•Dec 2, 1929•237 citations
The aim of this paper is to discuss in a pedagogical way the problem of the emergence of classical behaviour in certain physical systems which, in principle, are correctly described by quantum mechanics. It is stressed that the limit ℏ → 0 is not sufficient and the crucial role played by the environment must be taken into account. In particular, recalled is the old problem raised by Mott in 1929 ( Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 126 79) concerning the straight tracks observed in a cloud chamber, produced by an α-particle emitted by a source in the form of a spherical wave. The conceptual relevance of the problem for a clearer understanding of the classical limit is discussed in a historical perspective. Moreover, a simple mathematical model is proposed, where the result of Mott is obtained in a rigorous mathematical way.
This note deals with models of quantum systems where the emergence of a classical behavior can be concretely analyzed. We first briefly review some well known difficulties arising in the classical limit of quantum mechanics according to the Copenhagen interpretation. Then we discuss the seminal contribution by Mott (1929) on the tracks observed in a cloud chamber, where the problem can be approached in a particularly transparent way. Finally, we propose a model Hamiltonian, with interaction described by spin dependent point interactions, where Mott’s analysis can be rephrased and the result can be rigorously formulated.
I review and augment my work of the last few years on the physical origins and limitations of canonical quantum measurement behavior. Central to this work is a detailed analysis of the microstructure of real measurement devices. Particular attention is paid to the Mott problem, which addresses a simpler version of canonical quantum measurement behavior: It asks why an Alpha particle emitted in nuclear decay produces one and only one track in a cloud chamber. My analysis - entirely consistent with unitarity - leads to an emergent, approximate Born rule supported by experiment, with possible breakdown at very small probability density. I argue that a similar picture applies to other measurement scenarios, including Geiger counters, the Stern-Gerlach experiment and superconducting qubits.
Conceptual and formal problems Many of the problems surrounding the interpretation of quantum mechanics stem from the absence of a sufficiently general and physically transparent analysis of the connection with the domain in which classical concepts are assumed to apply. It is the purpose of this chapter to describe with the aid of a few examples how the quantum potential approach provides a context within which the conceptual and formal issues raised by this problem may be clarified. A key question is to explain how the state or context dependence which is so characteristic of the quantum domain turns into state independence at a certain level, characterized as ‘classical’. To illustrate one aspect of the conceptual problem we recall that in Bohr's interpretation the validity of classical concepts is already presupposed since, it is suggested, it is only in terms of these that one can unambiguously communicate the results of experiments in the quantum domain. Thus, classical physics must be considered as prior to quantum mechanics and the latter is a generalization of the former in that it provides a new set of laws governing the application of classical concepts. According to this view, any procedure by which classical mechanics is recovered from quantum mechanics as a mathematical limit can only be a demonstration of consistency with the already postulated epistemological relation between the two theories and not as a ‘derivation’ of classical mechanics from quantum mechanics (George, Prigogine & Rosenfeld, 1972).
At present there is a consensus about the fact that the emergence of the classical world from the underlying quantum reality involves the physical phenomenon of decoherence, which is usually studied in the version proposed by Zurek and his collaborators. According to this version, decoherence is a process resulting from the interaction between a quantum system and its environment (environment-induced decoherence, EID); this process singles out the observables that receive definite classical values. The aim of this paper is to propose a top-down approach to decoherence, which takes the perspective of the whole closed system, and considers whether each set of degrees of freedom decoheres or not. This approach is more general than the orthodox open-system perspective and dissolves some of its conceptual problems. Although decoherence becomes relative to the way in which the closed system is decomposed, the quantum-to-classical transition defines unequivocally the realm of classicality by identifying the observables with classical-like behavior.
The Mott problem concerns a long-standing paradox in quantum mechanics: although alpha-particle wavefunctions emitted from radioactive sources are spherically symmetric, cloud chambers consistently record straight-line tracks. Standard explanations rely on decoherence, probabilistic branching, or implicit classical assumptions, yet none fully resolve how directional trajectories emerge from an initially isotropic quantum state. This paper presents a geometric interpretation of the Mott problem within the Dimensional Evolution (DE) framework, in which wavefunction collapse is treated as a resonance- and identity-mediated geometric process rather than a purely probabilistic event. Measurement is modeled as a structured interaction between system and detector identity wells, producing directional collapse funnels that anchor sequential localization events. Trajectory formation is described as a process of coherent tether crystallization, whereby successive measurement interactions align collapse curvature along a stable resonant direction. Straight tracks arise not from classical particle paths, but from the geometric reinforcement of collapse orientation through detector–system coupling. Inverse-domain resonance matching replaces environment-driven decoherence as the primary mechanism governing localization. The DE approach resolves the Mott paradox without invoking hidden variables, many-worlds branching, or ad hoc classical transitions, and provides a unified geometric explanation for trajectory emergence in quantum measurement systems. Implications for quantum foundations, measurement theory, and experimental testability are discussed.
Abstract The present note is suggested by a recent paper by Prof. Darwin,* and is intended to show how one of the most typically particle-like properties of matter can be derived from the wave mechanics. In the theory of radioactive disintegration, as presented by Gamow, the ∝-particle is represented by a spherical wave which slowly leaks out of the nucleus. On the other hand, the ∝-particle, once emerged, has particle-like properties, the most striking being the ray tracks that it forms in a Wilson cloud chamber. It is a little difficult to picture how it is that an outgoing spherical wave can produce a straight track ; we think intuitively that it should ionise atoms at random throughout space. We could consider that Gamow’s outgoing spherical wave should give the probability of disintegration, but that, when the particle is outside the nucleus, it should be represented by a wave packet moving in a definite direction, so as to produce a straight track. But it ought not to be necessary to do this. The wave mechanics unaided ought to be able to predict the possible results of any observation that we could make on a system, without invoking, until the moment at which the observation is made, the classical particle-like properties of the electrons or α-particles forming that system. If we consider the ∝-ray alone as the system under consideration, then the gas of the Wilson chamber must be considered as the means by which we observe the particle ; so in this case we must consider the ∝-ray as α-particle as soon as it is outside the nucleus, because that is the moment at which the observation is made. If, however, we consider the α-particle and the gas together as one system, then it is ionised atoms that we observe ; interpreting the wave function should give us simply the probability that such and such an atom is ionised. Until this final interpretation is made, no mention should be made of the ∝-ray being a particle at all. The difficulty that we have in picturing how it is that a spherical wave can produce a straight track arises from our tendency to picture the wave as existing in ordinary three dimensional space, whereas we are really dealing with wave functions in the multispace formed by the co-ordinates both of the α-particle and of every atom in the Wilson chamber.