Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0903.0427 · Mexican School of Particles and Fields

Perturbative Quantum Analysis and Classical Limit of the Electron Scattering by a Solenoidal Magnetic Field

Gabriela Murguía, Matías Moreno, Manuel Torres

Published Jan 1, 2009• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A well known example in quantum electrodynamics (QED) shows that Coulomb scattering of unpolarized electrons, calculated to lowest order in perturbation theory, yields a results that exactly coincides (in the non‐relativistic limit) with the Rutherford formula. We examine an analogous example, the classical and perturbative quantum scattering of an electron by a magnetic field confined in an infinite solenoid of finite radius. The results obtained for the classical and the quantum differential cross sections display marked differences. While this may not be a complete surprise, one should expect to recover the classical expression by applying the classical limit to the quantum result. This turn not to be the case. Surprisingly enough, it is shown that the classical result can not be recuperated even if higher order corrections are included. To recover the classic correspondence of the quantum scattering problem a suitable non‐perturbative methodology should be applied.

DOI
10.1063/1.3131576

Related papers

Quantum versus classical scattering of Dirac particles by a solenoidal magnetic field and the correspondence principle

Gabriela Murguía, Moreno, Matias, Manuel Torres

We present a detailed analysis of the scattering of charged particles by the magnetic field of a long solenoid of constant magnetic flux and finite radius. We study the relativistic and non-relativistic quantum and classical scenarios. The classical limit of the perturbative quantum expressions, understood as the Planck's limit (making $\hbar$ going to zero) is analyzed and compared with the classical result. The classical cross section shows a general non-symmetric behavior with respect to the scattering angle in contradistinction to the quantum calculations performed so far. The various regimes analyzed show that the quantum cross sections do not satisfy the correspondence principle: they do not reduce to the classical result in any considered limit, an argument in favor of the interpretation of the process as a purely quantum phenomenon. We conclude that in order to restore the classical correspondence of the phenomenon, a complete non-perturbative quantum calculation for a finite solenoid radius is required.

arXiv:quant-ph/0407123•Jul 15, 2004•0 citations

Classical limit for the scattering of Dirac particles in a magnetic field

G Murgu a, M Moreno

We present a relativistic quantum calculation at first order in perturbation theory of the differential cross section for a Dirac particle scattered by a solenoidal magnetic field. The resulting cross section is symmetric in the scattering angle as those obtained by Aharonov and Bohm (AB) in the string limit and by Landau and Lifshitz (LL) for the non-relativistic case. We show that taking pr 0 |sin (θ/2)|/ ≪ 1 in our expression of the differential cross section it reduces to the one reported by AB, and if additionally we assume θ ≪ 1 our result becomes the one obtained by LL. However, these limits are explicitly singular in as opposed to our initial result. We analyse the singular behaviour in and show that the perturbative Planck limit ( → 0) is consistent, in contrast to those of the AB and LL expressions. We also discuss the scattering in a uniform and constant magnetic field, which resembles some features of QCD.

arXiv:quant-ph/0211195•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Feb 26, 2003•1 citation

Quantum effects in the scattering by the magnetic field of a solenoid

Gabriela Murguía, Moreno, Matias

We present a relativistic quantum calculation at first order in perturbation theory of the differential cross section for a Dirac particle scattered by the magnetic field of a solenoid. The resulting cross section is symmetric in the scattering angle as those obtained by Aharonov and Bohm (AB) in the string limit and by Landau and Lifshitz (LL) for the non relativistic case. We show that taking pr_0 sin(theta/2) << 1 in our expression of the differential cross section it reduces to that one reported by AB, and if additionally we assume theta << 1 our result becomes the one obtained by LL. However, these limits are explicitly singular in hbar as opposed to our initial result. We analyse the singular behavior in hbar and show that the perturbative Planck limit (hbar -> 0) is consistent, contrarily to those of the AB and LL expressions.

arXiv:physics/0202020•Feb 7, 2002•0 citations

Electron scattering by a solenoid

Igor Viktorovich Tyutin

The quantum-mechanical problems of electron scattering by an infinitely thin solenoid and by a half of an infinitely thin solenoid are examined from the viewpoint of constructing a self-adjoint Hamiltonian. It is demonstrated that in both problems there exist unique self-adjoint operators with a ``non-singular'' domain, that, due to physical reasons, are identified with the corresponding Hamiltonians. In the case of quantized values of magnetic flow along the solenoid, the electron does not experience any scattering by the string. It is shown that the scattering amplitude and wave function of an electron in the problem of scattering by an infinitely long solenoid of radius a in the limit a->0 turn into the corresponding expressions for the problem of an infinitely thin solenoid. In particular, at a quantized value of magnetic flow along the solenoid, scattering disappears at a->0.

arXiv:0801.2167•Jan 14, 2008•15 citations

Rutherford Scattering: a comparison between Classical Mechanics, Non-Relativistic Quantum Mechanics, and Quantum Field Theory

José Orlando Rodrigues da Cunha Filho, Lucas de Castro Rodrigues Barros

This is a review article that investigates the three approaches to Rutherford Scattering Theory - Classical Mechanics, Non-Relativistic Quantum Mechanics, and Quantum Field Theory - and their distinctions. In the first sections, the mathematical models are demonstrated and a qualitative analysis of the main differences in each interpretation of the phenomenon is performed. Next, numerical simulations show the effects of dealing with relativistic or non-relativistic limits. The results make it clear that no theory is essentially wrong, but the newer ones are just more complete and consider more relevant parameters.

•Dec 21, 2021•0 citations

Aharonov-Bohm effect as a scattering event

Yakir Aharonov, C. K. Au, E. C. Lerner +1 more

The Aharonov-Bohm effect is reconsidered as a scattering event of an electron by a magnetic field confined in an infinite solenoid of finite radius both in the situation where the solenoid is penetrable as well as impenetrable. We next discuss the validity of the Born approximation for the partial-wave scattering amplitudes and explain why for the cylindrically symmetric $(m=0)$ partial wave the first Born approximation fails in the long-wavelength limit or as the radius of the solenoid shrinks to zero.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•May 15, 1984•58 citations
A well known example in quantum electrodynamics (QED) shows that Coulomb scattering of unpolarized electrons, calculated to lowest order in perturbation theory, yields a results that exactly coincides (in the non‐relativistic limit) with the Rutherford formula. We examine an analogous example, the classical and perturbative quantum scattering of an electron by a magnetic field confined in an infinite solenoid of finite radius. The results obtained for the classical and the quantum differential cross sections display marked differences. While this may not be a complete surprise, one should expect to recover the classical expression by applying the classical limit to the quantum result. This turn not to be the case. Surprisingly enough, it is shown that the classical result can not be recuperated even if higher order corrections are included. To recover the classic correspondence of the quantum scattering problem a suitable non‐perturbative methodology should be applied.
We present a detailed analysis of the scattering of charged particles by the magnetic field of a long solenoid of constant magnetic flux and finite radius. We study the relativistic and non-relativistic quantum and classical scenarios. The classical limit of the perturbative quantum expressions, understood as the Planck's limit (making ℏ\hbarℏ going to zero) is analyzed and compared with the classical result. The classical cross section shows a general non-symmetric behavior with respect to the scattering angle in contradistinction to the quantum calculations performed so far. The various regimes analyzed show that the quantum cross sections do not satisfy the correspondence principle: they do not reduce to the classical result in any considered limit, an argument in favor of the interpretation of the process as a purely quantum phenomenon. We conclude that in order to restore the classical correspondence of the phenomenon, a complete non-perturbative quantum calculation for a finite solenoid radius is required.
We present a relativistic quantum calculation at first order in perturbation theory of the differential cross section for a Dirac particle scattered by a solenoidal magnetic field. The resulting cross section is symmetric in the scattering angle as those obtained by Aharonov and Bohm (AB) in the string limit and by Landau and Lifshitz (LL) for the non-relativistic case. We show that taking pr 0 |sin (θ/2)|/ ≪ 1 in our expression of the differential cross section it reduces to the one reported by AB, and if additionally we assume θ ≪ 1 our result becomes the one obtained by LL. However, these limits are explicitly singular in as opposed to our initial result. We analyse the singular behaviour in and show that the perturbative Planck limit ( → 0) is consistent, in contrast to those of the AB and LL expressions. We also discuss the scattering in a uniform and constant magnetic field, which resembles some features of QCD.
We present a relativistic quantum calculation at first order in perturbation theory of the differential cross section for a Dirac particle scattered by the magnetic field of a solenoid. The resulting cross section is symmetric in the scattering angle as those obtained by Aharonov and Bohm (AB) in the string limit and by Landau and Lifshitz (LL) for the non relativistic case. We show that taking pr_0 sin(theta/2) << 1 in our expression of the differential cross section it reduces to that one reported by AB, and if additionally we assume theta << 1 our result becomes the one obtained by LL. However, these limits are explicitly singular in hbar as opposed to our initial result. We analyse the singular behavior in hbar and show that the perturbative Planck limit (hbar -> 0) is consistent, contrarily to those of the AB and LL expressions.
The quantum-mechanical problems of electron scattering by an infinitely thin solenoid and by a half of an infinitely thin solenoid are examined from the viewpoint of constructing a self-adjoint Hamiltonian. It is demonstrated that in both problems there exist unique self-adjoint operators with a ``non-singular'' domain, that, due to physical reasons, are identified with the corresponding Hamiltonians. In the case of quantized values of magnetic flow along the solenoid, the electron does not experience any scattering by the string. It is shown that the scattering amplitude and wave function of an electron in the problem of scattering by an infinitely long solenoid of radius a in the limit a->0 turn into the corresponding expressions for the problem of an infinitely thin solenoid. In particular, at a quantized value of magnetic flow along the solenoid, scattering disappears at a->0.
This is a review article that investigates the three approaches to Rutherford Scattering Theory - Classical Mechanics, Non-Relativistic Quantum Mechanics, and Quantum Field Theory - and their distinctions. In the first sections, the mathematical models are demonstrated and a qualitative analysis of the main differences in each interpretation of the phenomenon is performed. Next, numerical simulations show the effects of dealing with relativistic or non-relativistic limits. The results make it clear that no theory is essentially wrong, but the newer ones are just more complete and consider more relevant parameters.
The Aharonov-Bohm effect is reconsidered as a scattering event of an electron by a magnetic field confined in an infinite solenoid of finite radius both in the situation where the solenoid is penetrable as well as impenetrable. We next discuss the validity of the Born approximation for the partial-wave scattering amplitudes and explain why for the cylindrically symmetric (m=0)(m=0)(m=0) partial wave the first Born approximation fails in the long-wavelength limit or as the radius of the solenoid shrinks to zero.