Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0901.4375

Extracting Spooky-activation-at-a-distance from Considerations of Entanglement

Peter Bruza, Kirsty Kitto, Douglas L. Nelson, Cathy L. McEvoy

Published Jan 27, 2009• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Following an early claim by Nelson & McEvoy \cite{Nelson:McEvoy:2007} suggesting that word associations can display `spooky action at a distance behaviour', a serious investigation of the potentially quantum nature of such associations is currently underway. This paper presents a simple quantum model of a word association system. It is shown that a quantum model of word entanglement can recover aspects of both the Spreading Activation equation and the Spooky-activation-at-a-distance equation, both of which are used to model the activation level of words in human memory.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.0901.4375

Related papers

Quantum-like models of human semantic space

Jerome R. Busemeyer, Peter Bruza

A connection between quantum theory and human memory came out of cybernetics research in the early 1950s (von Foerster, 1950). It was not until modelling the activation of a word in human memory did the connection begin to appear in mainstream psychological literature. Target word activation was speculated as being similar to quantum entanglement because the target word and its associative network were being activated “in synchrony,” the core intuition behind the “spooky-action-at-a-distance” formula (Nelson et al ., 2003). This chapter begins by developing a quantum-like model of the human mental lexicon and compares it against other memory models. Specific attention is paid to how these models describe the activation of a word in memory in the context of the extra- and intra-list cuing tasks. The chapter then covers how quantum theory can be applied to model human semantic space. The human mental lexicon A mental lexicon refers to the words that comprise a language, and its structure is defined here by the associative links that bind this vocabulary together. Such links are acquired through experience and the vast and semi-random nature of this experience ensures that words within this vocabulary are highly inter-connected, both directly and indirectly through other words. For example, the word planet becomes associated with earth, space, moon , and so on, and within this set, moon can become linked to earth and star . Words are so associatively interconnected with each other they meet the qualifications of a “small world” network wherein it takes only a few associative steps to move from any one word to any other in the lexicon (Steyvers & Tenenbaum, 2005).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jul 26, 2012•0 citations

Entangling words and meaning

Peter Bruza, Kirsty Kitto, R. Doug McEvoy +1 more

Human memory experiments appear to be generating "nonlocal" effects cite{Nelson:McEvoy:2007}. In this paper the possibility that words might be entangled in human semantic space is seriously entertained. This approach leads to a very natural picture of the way in which context might affect word association via the standard interpretation of quantum measurement. Two possible scenarios for testing such a hypothesis are suggested, both based upon potential violations of the CHSH inequality.

•Jan 1, 2008•53 citations

There Is No Action at a Distance in Quantum Mechanics, Spooky or Otherwise

S. P. Boughn

I feel compelled to respond to the frequent references to spooky action at a distance that often accompany reports of experiments investigating entangled quantum mechanical states. Most, but not all, of these articles have appeared in the popular press. As an experimentalist I have great admiration for such experiments and the concomitant advances in quantum information and quantum computing, but accompanying claims of action at a distance are quite simply nonsense. Some physicists and philosophers of science have bought into the story by promoting the nonlocal nature of quantum mechanics. In 1964, John Bell proved that classical hidden variable theories cannot reproduce the predictions of quantum mechanics unless they employ some type of action at a distance. I have no problem with this conclusion. Unfortunately, Bell later expanded his analysis and mistakenly deduced that quantum mechanics and by implication nature herself are nonlocal. In addition, some of these articles present Einstein in caricature, a tragic figure who neither understood quantum mechanics nor believed it to be an accurate theory of nature. Consequently, the current experiments have proven him wrong. This is also nonsense.

arXiv:1806.07925•Jan 1, 2018•5 citations

“Non-locality”

Richard Healey

Quantum entanglement is popularly believed to give rise to spooky action at a distance of a kind that Einstein decisively rejected. Indeed, important recent experiments on systems assigned entangled states have been claimed to refute Einstein by exhibiting such spooky action. After reviewing two considerations in favor of this view I argue that quantum theory can be used to explain puzzling correlations correctly predicted by assignment of entangled quantum states with no such instantaneous action at a distance. We owe both considerations in favor of the view to arguments of John Bell. I present simplified forms of these arguments as well as a game that provides insight into the situation. The argument I give in response turns on a prescriptive view of quantum states that differs both from Dirac’s (as stated in Chapter 2) and Einstein’s.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jul 20, 2017•0 citations

Quantum Entanglement: Spooky Action at a Distance

One of the strangest and most profound features of quantum mechanics is that two or more particles can become linked in such a way that the quantum state of one instantly determines the state of the other, no matter how far apart they are separated as shown in Fig. 17.1. This phenomenon is called quantum entanglement . It lies at the very heart of quantum mechanics and has been described by some as the most non-classical and non-intuitive aspect of the theory. Albert Einstein famously disliked it, referring to it as “spooky action at a distance.”. Far from being a mere curiosity, entanglement is now recognized as a fundamental resource that powers much of modern quantum technology, including quantum computing, quantum cryptography, and quantum teleportation. It also raises deep philosophical questions about the nature of reality, locality, and the interconnectedness of the universe.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Aug 31, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Entanglement: Spooky Action at a Distance

Stanley Gudder

Quantum entanglement is an important resource in quantum information technologies. Here, we study and characterize in a precise mathematical language some of the weird and nonintuitive features of quantum entanglement. We begin by illustrating why entanglement implies action at a distance. We then introduce a simple criterion for determining when a pure quantum state is entangled. Finally, we present a measure for the amount of entanglement for a pure state. Quanta 2020; 9: 1–6.

arXiv:2005.11870•Quanta•Jun 17, 2020•6 citations
Following an early claim by Nelson & McEvoy \cite{Nelson:McEvoy:2007} suggesting that word associations can display `spooky action at a distance behaviour', a serious investigation of the potentially quantum nature of such associations is currently underway. This paper presents a simple quantum model of a word association system. It is shown that a quantum model of word entanglement can recover aspects of both the Spreading Activation equation and the Spooky-activation-at-a-distance equation, both of which are used to model the activation level of words in human memory.
A connection between quantum theory and human memory came out of cybernetics research in the early 1950s (von Foerster, 1950). It was not until modelling the activation of a word in human memory did the connection begin to appear in mainstream psychological literature. Target word activation was speculated as being similar to quantum entanglement because the target word and its associative network were being activated “in synchrony,” the core intuition behind the “spooky-action-at-a-distance” formula (Nelson et al ., 2003). This chapter begins by developing a quantum-like model of the human mental lexicon and compares it against other memory models. Specific attention is paid to how these models describe the activation of a word in memory in the context of the extra- and intra-list cuing tasks. The chapter then covers how quantum theory can be applied to model human semantic space. The human mental lexicon A mental lexicon refers to the words that comprise a language, and its structure is defined here by the associative links that bind this vocabulary together. Such links are acquired through experience and the vast and semi-random nature of this experience ensures that words within this vocabulary are highly inter-connected, both directly and indirectly through other words. For example, the word planet becomes associated with earth, space, moon , and so on, and within this set, moon can become linked to earth and star . Words are so associatively interconnected with each other they meet the qualifications of a “small world” network wherein it takes only a few associative steps to move from any one word to any other in the lexicon (Steyvers & Tenenbaum, 2005).
Human memory experiments appear to be generating "nonlocal" effects cite{Nelson:McEvoy:2007}. In this paper the possibility that words might be entangled in human semantic space is seriously entertained. This approach leads to a very natural picture of the way in which context might affect word association via the standard interpretation of quantum measurement. Two possible scenarios for testing such a hypothesis are suggested, both based upon potential violations of the CHSH inequality.
I feel compelled to respond to the frequent references to spooky action at a distance that often accompany reports of experiments investigating entangled quantum mechanical states. Most, but not all, of these articles have appeared in the popular press. As an experimentalist I have great admiration for such experiments and the concomitant advances in quantum information and quantum computing, but accompanying claims of action at a distance are quite simply nonsense. Some physicists and philosophers of science have bought into the story by promoting the nonlocal nature of quantum mechanics. In 1964, John Bell proved that classical hidden variable theories cannot reproduce the predictions of quantum mechanics unless they employ some type of action at a distance. I have no problem with this conclusion. Unfortunately, Bell later expanded his analysis and mistakenly deduced that quantum mechanics and by implication nature herself are nonlocal. In addition, some of these articles present Einstein in caricature, a tragic figure who neither understood quantum mechanics nor believed it to be an accurate theory of nature. Consequently, the current experiments have proven him wrong. This is also nonsense.
Quantum entanglement is popularly believed to give rise to spooky action at a distance of a kind that Einstein decisively rejected. Indeed, important recent experiments on systems assigned entangled states have been claimed to refute Einstein by exhibiting such spooky action. After reviewing two considerations in favor of this view I argue that quantum theory can be used to explain puzzling correlations correctly predicted by assignment of entangled quantum states with no such instantaneous action at a distance. We owe both considerations in favor of the view to arguments of John Bell. I present simplified forms of these arguments as well as a game that provides insight into the situation. The argument I give in response turns on a prescriptive view of quantum states that differs both from Dirac’s (as stated in Chapter 2) and Einstein’s.
One of the strangest and most profound features of quantum mechanics is that two or more particles can become linked in such a way that the quantum state of one instantly determines the state of the other, no matter how far apart they are separated as shown in Fig. 17.1. This phenomenon is called quantum entanglement . It lies at the very heart of quantum mechanics and has been described by some as the most non-classical and non-intuitive aspect of the theory. Albert Einstein famously disliked it, referring to it as “spooky action at a distance.”. Far from being a mere curiosity, entanglement is now recognized as a fundamental resource that powers much of modern quantum technology, including quantum computing, quantum cryptography, and quantum teleportation. It also raises deep philosophical questions about the nature of reality, locality, and the interconnectedness of the universe.