Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0901.0811 · Open Systems & Information Dynamics

Quantum Memory as a Perpetuum Mobile? Stability vs. Reversibility of Information Processing

Robert Alicki

Published Sep 1, 2012• 12 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is argued using a Gedankenexperiment that a scalable quantum memory could be used as a perpetuum mobile of the second kind and hence cannot be realized in nature. The reasoning is based on the assumption that the Landauer's principle for measurements is a consequence of the second law of thermodynamics and not an independent postulate. This implies a modification of the Landauer's principle when applied for discrimination of equilibrium (metastable) states. While identification of the metastable state can be done at infinitesimally low cost, any change of such state involves dissipation of energy proportional to its stability factor.

DOI
10.1142/s1230161212500163

Related papers

Quantum memories and Landauer's principle

Robert Alicki

Two types of arguments concerning (im)possibility of constructing a scalable, exponentially stable quantum memory equipped with Hamiltonian controls are discussed. The first type concerns ergodic properties of open Kitaev models which are considered as promising candidates for such memories. It is shown that, although the 4D Kitaev model provides stable qubit observables, the Hamiltonian control is not possible. The thermodynamical approach leads to the new proposal of the revised version of Landauer's principle and suggests that the existence of quantum memory implies the existence of the perpetuum mobile of the second kind. Finally, a discussion of the stability property of information and its implications is presented.

arXiv:1007.1089•Oct 1, 2010•1 citation

Landauer's principle in the quantum domain

Janet Anders, Saroosh Shabbir, Stefanie Hilt +1 more

Recent papers discussing thermodynamic processes in strongly coupled quantum systems claim a violation of Landauer's principle and imply a violation of the second law of thermodynamics. If true, this would have powerful consequences. Perpetuum mobiles could be build as long as the operating temperature is brought close to zero. It would also have serious consequences on thermodynamic derivations of information theoretic results, such as the Holevo bound. Here we argue why these claims are erroneous. Correlations occurring in the strongly coupled, quantum domain require a rethink of how entropy, heat and work are calculated. It is shown that a consistent treatment solves the paradox.

arXiv:1006.1420•Electronic Proceedings in Theoretical Computer Science•Jun 9, 2010•12 citations

About Perpetuum Mobile without Emotions

А. В. Никулов

It is noted that old belief in impossibility of any perpetuum mobile is the basis of the great confidence in the second law of thermodynamics. The Carnot’s principle, «called with the time of Rudolf Clausius as the second law of thermodynamics», was based on this belief and this belief saved the second law in the beginning of 20 century when absolute randomness of any Brownian motion, perpetual motion experimentally observed, was postulated. It is shown that this postulate is not correct according to quantum mechanics. Moreover experimental evidence of its violation is known. Violation of this postulate means violation of the second law and a possibility of useful perpetuum mobile.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2002•7 citations

Can one build a quantum hard drive? A no-go theorem for storing quantum information in equilibrium systems

Robert Alicki, Michał Horodecki

We prove a no-go theorem for storing quantum information in equilibrium systems. Namely, quantum information cannot be stored in a system with time-independent Hamiltonian interacting with heat bath of temperature $T>0$ during time that grows with the number of used qubits. We prove it by showing, that storing quantum information for macroscopic time would imply existence of perpetuum mobile of the second kind. The general results are illustrated by the Kitaev model of quantum memory. In contrast, classical information can be stored in equilibrium states for arbitrary long times. We show how it is possible via phase-transition type phenomena. Our result shows that there is a fundamental difference between quantum and classical information in {\it physical} terms.

arXiv:quant-ph/0603260•Mar 28, 2006•16 citations

Stability versus reversibility in information processing

Robert Alicki

The paper is motivated by the discussion of feasibility of large scale quantum computations which should incorporate both unitarity of quantum dynamics for information bearing degrees of freedom and stability with respect to environmental noise. The minimal thermodynamic cost of a single CNOT gate, which is equivalent to the minimal cost of a quantum measurement of a binary observable is analyzed using a generic quantum model of one bit memory. For this model stability of memory with respect to thermal and quantum noise and the error of readout can be quantified. One obtains the relations between the minimal work which is invested in a measurement or CNOT gate, the error and the stability factor. The basic formula differs from the standard Landauer one and seems to be much more realistic. The results show the fundamental conflict between stability and irreversibility of information processing. This explains the feasibility of classical stable and scalable information processing performed by irreversible gates and suggests impossibility of large scale quantum computations based on unitary gates.

International Journal of Modern Physics Conference Series•Jan 1, 2014•12 citations

Statistical thermodynamics of quantum Brownian motion: Birth of perpetuum mobile of the second kind

Theo M. Nieuwenhuizen, ARMEN E. ALLAHVERDYAN

The Brownian motion of a quantum particle in a harmonic confining potential and coupled to a harmonic quantum thermal bath is exactly solvable. It is shown that at low enough temperatures the stationary state is non-Gibbsian due to an entanglement with the bath. In physical terms, this happens when the cloud of bath modes around the particle starts to play a non-trivial role. Indeed, equilibrium thermodynamics of the total system, particle plus bath, does not imply standard equilibrium thermodynamics for the particle itself at low $T$. Various formulations of the second law are found to be invalid at low $T$. First, the Clausius inequality can be violated, because heat can be extracted from the zero point energy of the cloud of bath modes. Second, when the width of the confining potential is suddenly changed, there occurs a relaxation to equilibrium during which the entropy production is partly negative. Third, for non-adiabatic changes of system parameters the rate of energy dissipation can be negative, and, out of equilibrium, cyclic processes are possible which extract work from the bath. Conditions are put forward under which perpetuum mobile of the second kind, having one or several work extraction cycles, enter the realm of condensed matter physics. Fourth, it follows that the equivalence between different formulations of the second law (e.g. those by Clausius and Thomson) can be violated at low temperatures. These effects are the consequence of quantum entanglement in the presence of the slightly off-equilibrium nature of the thermal bath, and become important when the characteristic quantum time scale $\hbar/k_BT$ is larger than or comparable to other timescale of the system. They show that there is no general consensus between standard thermodynamics and quantum mechanics.

arXiv:cond-mat/0011389•Nov 22, 2000•15 citations
It is argued using a Gedankenexperiment that a scalable quantum memory could be used as a perpetuum mobile of the second kind and hence cannot be realized in nature. The reasoning is based on the assumption that the Landauer's principle for measurements is a consequence of the second law of thermodynamics and not an independent postulate. This implies a modification of the Landauer's principle when applied for discrimination of equilibrium (metastable) states. While identification of the metastable state can be done at infinitesimally low cost, any change of such state involves dissipation of energy proportional to its stability factor.
Two types of arguments concerning (im)possibility of constructing a scalable, exponentially stable quantum memory equipped with Hamiltonian controls are discussed. The first type concerns ergodic properties of open Kitaev models which are considered as promising candidates for such memories. It is shown that, although the 4D Kitaev model provides stable qubit observables, the Hamiltonian control is not possible. The thermodynamical approach leads to the new proposal of the revised version of Landauer's principle and suggests that the existence of quantum memory implies the existence of the perpetuum mobile of the second kind. Finally, a discussion of the stability property of information and its implications is presented.
Recent papers discussing thermodynamic processes in strongly coupled quantum systems claim a violation of Landauer's principle and imply a violation of the second law of thermodynamics. If true, this would have powerful consequences. Perpetuum mobiles could be build as long as the operating temperature is brought close to zero. It would also have serious consequences on thermodynamic derivations of information theoretic results, such as the Holevo bound. Here we argue why these claims are erroneous. Correlations occurring in the strongly coupled, quantum domain require a rethink of how entropy, heat and work are calculated. It is shown that a consistent treatment solves the paradox.
It is noted that old belief in impossibility of any perpetuum mobile is the basis of the great confidence in the second law of thermodynamics. The Carnot’s principle, «called with the time of Rudolf Clausius as the second law of thermodynamics», was based on this belief and this belief saved the second law in the beginning of 20 century when absolute randomness of any Brownian motion, perpetual motion experimentally observed, was postulated. It is shown that this postulate is not correct according to quantum mechanics. Moreover experimental evidence of its violation is known. Violation of this postulate means violation of the second law and a possibility of useful perpetuum mobile.
We prove a no-go theorem for storing quantum information in equilibrium systems. Namely, quantum information cannot be stored in a system with time-independent Hamiltonian interacting with heat bath of temperature T>0T>0T>0 during time that grows with the number of used qubits. We prove it by showing, that storing quantum information for macroscopic time would imply existence of perpetuum mobile of the second kind. The general results are illustrated by the Kitaev model of quantum memory. In contrast, classical information can be stored in equilibrium states for arbitrary long times. We show how it is possible via phase-transition type phenomena. Our result shows that there is a fundamental difference between quantum and classical information in {\it physical} terms.
The paper is motivated by the discussion of feasibility of large scale quantum computations which should incorporate both unitarity of quantum dynamics for information bearing degrees of freedom and stability with respect to environmental noise. The minimal thermodynamic cost of a single CNOT gate, which is equivalent to the minimal cost of a quantum measurement of a binary observable is analyzed using a generic quantum model of one bit memory. For this model stability of memory with respect to thermal and quantum noise and the error of readout can be quantified. One obtains the relations between the minimal work which is invested in a measurement or CNOT gate, the error and the stability factor. The basic formula differs from the standard Landauer one and seems to be much more realistic. The results show the fundamental conflict between stability and irreversibility of information processing. This explains the feasibility of classical stable and scalable information processing performed by irreversible gates and suggests impossibility of large scale quantum computations based on unitary gates.
The Brownian motion of a quantum particle in a harmonic confining potential and coupled to a harmonic quantum thermal bath is exactly solvable. It is shown that at low enough temperatures the stationary state is non-Gibbsian due to an entanglement with the bath. In physical terms, this happens when the cloud of bath modes around the particle starts to play a non-trivial role. Indeed, equilibrium thermodynamics of the total system, particle plus bath, does not imply standard equilibrium thermodynamics for the particle itself at low TTT. Various formulations of the second law are found to be invalid at low TTT. First, the Clausius inequality can be violated, because heat can be extracted from the zero point energy of the cloud of bath modes. Second, when the width of the confining potential is suddenly changed, there occurs a relaxation to equilibrium during which the entropy production is partly negative. Third, for non-adiabatic changes of system parameters the rate of energy dissipation can be negative, and, out of equilibrium, cyclic processes are possible which extract work from the bath. Conditions are put forward under which perpetuum mobile of the second kind, having one or several work extraction cycles, enter the realm of condensed matter physics. Fourth, it follows that the equivalence between different formulations of the second law (e.g. those by Clausius and Thomson) can be violated at low temperatures. These effects are the consequence of quantum entanglement in the presence of the slightly off-equilibrium nature of the thermal bath, and become important when the characteristic quantum time scale ℏ/kBT\hbar/k_BTℏ/kB​T is larger than or comparable to other timescale of the system. They show that there is no general consensus between standard thermodynamics and quantum mechanics.