Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0810.3316

Two puzzling problems in explanation of the linear Stark effect of hydrogen atom and space quantization of the dipole moment

Pei-Lin You, Xiang-You Huang

Published Oct 18, 2008• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The linear Stark effect for the first excited state of the hydrogen atom shows that, in the unperturbed states, the atom has a permanent electric dipole moment (EDM) of magnitude 3eao (ao is Bohr radius). The EDM is not induce by the external field but is inherent behavior of the atom. But the calculation of quantum mechanics tells us that unperturbed states of hydrogen atom have no EDM! In the effect, two of four states have no energy shift. What are the EDM of the hydrogen atoms in the two states? Quantum mechanics can not answer the problem. The statement that the EDM of the two states is perpendicular to the field only comes from guesses in quantum mechanics. The two problems had puzzled physicists for more than 80 years. By introducing a new parameter this article gives a satisfactory explanation for the effect. Our calculation discovered that, in the unperturbed states, the atoms not only have EDM with 3eao but also can have only three directions of quantization! It is an entirely unexpected discovery. This research is a vital clue that not all is well with quantum mechanics. We prophesy that hydrogen-like atoms, such as K, Rb and Cs atom etc, may have large EDM of the order of magnitude eao in their ground state (see arXiv:0809.4767, arXiv:0810.0770 and arXiv:0810.2026).

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.0810.3316

Related papers

Electric dipole moments of lithium atoms in Rydberg states

Hui-Jie Dong, Ke-Shu Huang, Changyong Li +3 more

Recently, the diverse properties of Rydberg atoms, which probably arise from its large electric dipole moment (EDM), have been explored. In this paper, we report electric dipole moments along with Stark energies and charge densities of lithium Rydberg states in the presence of electric fields, calculated by matrix diagonalization. Huge electric dipole moments are discovered. In order to check the validity of the EDMs, we also use these electric dipole moments to calculate the Stark energies by numerical integration. The results agree with those calculated by matrix diagonalization.

Chinese Physics B•Sep 1, 2014•3 citations

Permanent Electric Dipole Moment of Hydrogen Atom

Weimin Du

The permanent electric dipole moment (PEDM) of hydrogen atom is calculated in classical mechanics and double-wave mechanics. The result of double-wave mechanics accords with the other result in classical limit. Because one wavefunction only describes an ensemble, the explanation to PEDM of hydrogen atom in orthodox quantum theory is difficult and unnatural. The classical mechanics and double-wave quantum mechanics could definitively describe single particle's action, and the calculations and explanations to PEDM in these two theories are more natural and reasonable.

Acta Sinica Quantum Optica•Jan 1, 2004•0 citations

Stark effect of Kramers-Henneberger atoms

Min Li, Qi Wei

The Electric Stark effect of a Kramers-Henneberger (KH) state of hydrogen atoms in both linearly and circularly polarized laser fields is studied. For the ground KH state of H atoms with a small quiver amplitude, the quadratic Stark effect is observed. For a large quiver amplitude, the Stark effect is quadratic only in a weak electric field and quickly changes to linear as the electric field increases. The atomic structure of the KH state is very sensitive to the electric field and can be easily polarized. The huge polarizability and induced dipole moment are comparable to those of Rydberg atoms.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•May 11, 2018•7 citations

Numerical evaluation of energy shifts due to dipole moments interaction in a hydrogen atom

Otor Daniel Abi, Anene Gerald Makuachukwu, Ominyi Daniel Sunday +2 more

This study aimed to numerically investigate the impact of dipole-dipole interactions on the energy levels of a hydrogen atom, specifically the energy shift caused by the interaction of the atom's dipole moment with external electric fields. This research involved applying perturbation theory and numerical techniques to quantify the changes in energy levels due to dipole orientations and magnitudes, contributing to a deeper understanding of atomic behavior and its implications in various scientific disciplines. The results presented showed that the wavefunction of the hydrogen atom exhibits degeneracy, especially n=2, n=3 states. This implies that n=2, n=3, have different states but the same energy as a result of the subshells with angular momentum l, which contains 2l+1 distinct state corresponding to positive value of m (magnetic angular momentum quantum number) m=-l±1. The total degeneracy of the energy levels n is caused by n2. We find out that as the orientation of the electron charges (θ,ϕ) change the dipole moment also changes and thus has a perturbing effect on the energy levels of the hydrogen atom leading to a shift in its energy. This is confirmed, as the energy shift increases slightly from the ground state energy function Φ100 to the second exicted state Φ300, while the degeneracy state of Φ310 experiences infinitesimal energy shift above. This is because the probability of the electron been found in the lower energy level is greater than at higher energy level and so it is mostly affected there by energy shift. Also, the dipole moment could increase liberational energy of the atom and thus lead to more excitement even though its impact is quite negative. The outcome of this study could have implications in precision measurements, quantum computing, and the understanding of complex atomic systems.

African Scientific Reports•Apr 14, 2026•0 citations

Stark Effect of the Lymann Alpha Line by a Rotating Electric Field

Tsutomu Ishimura

Wave functions of a hydrogen atom perturbed by an electric field are calculated under the assumption of a first-order Stark effect. It is assumed that the strength of the perturbation field is constant and its direction rotates around a fixed axis with a constant angular velocity. The ground state of the atom is not affected by the perturbation field. The energy level of the first excited state of the perturbed atom splits into nine sub-levels. The Lymann alpha line emitted from the perturbed atom consists of seven components. In the case where the angular velocity of the field rotation is small, the structure of the line is similar to that of the line emitted from an atom perturbed by a static field. In the case where, the angular velocity is large, it is similar to that of the line emitted from an unperturbed atom.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Aug 1, 1967•16 citations

Classical examination of the Stark effect in hydrogen

Andrew C. Hooker, Chris H. Greene, William Clark

The response of a hydrogen atom to a perturbative electric field is presented from a classical viewpoint. We find classical energy shifts in the hydrogen atom in situations that correspond to both the linear and quadratic Stark effects. We then compare these energy shifts to the exact quantum-mechanical values for the Stark effect. We find that the linear Stark effect can be accurately reproduced classically (given the correct initial conditions). In contrast, quantum-mechanical results for the quadratic Stark effect cannot be accurately reproduced classically, except in the correspondence principle limit of large principal quantum numbers n.

Physical Review A•Jun 1, 1997•17 citations
The linear Stark effect for the first excited state of the hydrogen atom shows that, in the unperturbed states, the atom has a permanent electric dipole moment (EDM) of magnitude 3eao (ao is Bohr radius). The EDM is not induce by the external field but is inherent behavior of the atom. But the calculation of quantum mechanics tells us that unperturbed states of hydrogen atom have no EDM! In the effect, two of four states have no energy shift. What are the EDM of the hydrogen atoms in the two states? Quantum mechanics can not answer the problem. The statement that the EDM of the two states is perpendicular to the field only comes from guesses in quantum mechanics. The two problems had puzzled physicists for more than 80 years. By introducing a new parameter this article gives a satisfactory explanation for the effect. Our calculation discovered that, in the unperturbed states, the atoms not only have EDM with 3eao but also can have only three directions of quantization! It is an entirely unexpected discovery. This research is a vital clue that not all is well with quantum mechanics. We prophesy that hydrogen-like atoms, such as K, Rb and Cs atom etc, may have large EDM of the order of magnitude eao in their ground state (see arXiv:0809.4767, arXiv:0810.0770 and arXiv:0810.2026).
Recently, the diverse properties of Rydberg atoms, which probably arise from its large electric dipole moment (EDM), have been explored. In this paper, we report electric dipole moments along with Stark energies and charge densities of lithium Rydberg states in the presence of electric fields, calculated by matrix diagonalization. Huge electric dipole moments are discovered. In order to check the validity of the EDMs, we also use these electric dipole moments to calculate the Stark energies by numerical integration. The results agree with those calculated by matrix diagonalization.
The permanent electric dipole moment (PEDM) of hydrogen atom is calculated in classical mechanics and double-wave mechanics. The result of double-wave mechanics accords with the other result in classical limit. Because one wavefunction only describes an ensemble, the explanation to PEDM of hydrogen atom in orthodox quantum theory is difficult and unnatural. The classical mechanics and double-wave quantum mechanics could definitively describe single particle's action, and the calculations and explanations to PEDM in these two theories are more natural and reasonable.
The Electric Stark effect of a Kramers-Henneberger (KH) state of hydrogen atoms in both linearly and circularly polarized laser fields is studied. For the ground KH state of H atoms with a small quiver amplitude, the quadratic Stark effect is observed. For a large quiver amplitude, the Stark effect is quadratic only in a weak electric field and quickly changes to linear as the electric field increases. The atomic structure of the KH state is very sensitive to the electric field and can be easily polarized. The huge polarizability and induced dipole moment are comparable to those of Rydberg atoms.
This study aimed to numerically investigate the impact of dipole-dipole interactions on the energy levels of a hydrogen atom, specifically the energy shift caused by the interaction of the atom's dipole moment with external electric fields. This research involved applying perturbation theory and numerical techniques to quantify the changes in energy levels due to dipole orientations and magnitudes, contributing to a deeper understanding of atomic behavior and its implications in various scientific disciplines. The results presented showed that the wavefunction of the hydrogen atom exhibits degeneracy, especially n=2, n=3 states. This implies that n=2, n=3, have different states but the same energy as a result of the subshells with angular momentum l, which contains 2l+1 distinct state corresponding to positive value of m (magnetic angular momentum quantum number) m=-l±1. The total degeneracy of the energy levels n is caused by n2. We find out that as the orientation of the electron charges (θ,ϕ) change the dipole moment also changes and thus has a perturbing effect on the energy levels of the hydrogen atom leading to a shift in its energy. This is confirmed, as the energy shift increases slightly from the ground state energy function Φ100 to the second exicted state Φ300, while the degeneracy state of Φ310 experiences infinitesimal energy shift above. This is because the probability of the electron been found in the lower energy level is greater than at higher energy level and so it is mostly affected there by energy shift. Also, the dipole moment could increase liberational energy of the atom and thus lead to more excitement even though its impact is quite negative. The outcome of this study could have implications in precision measurements, quantum computing, and the understanding of complex atomic systems.
Wave functions of a hydrogen atom perturbed by an electric field are calculated under the assumption of a first-order Stark effect. It is assumed that the strength of the perturbation field is constant and its direction rotates around a fixed axis with a constant angular velocity. The ground state of the atom is not affected by the perturbation field. The energy level of the first excited state of the perturbed atom splits into nine sub-levels. The Lymann alpha line emitted from the perturbed atom consists of seven components. In the case where the angular velocity of the field rotation is small, the structure of the line is similar to that of the line emitted from an atom perturbed by a static field. In the case where, the angular velocity is large, it is similar to that of the line emitted from an unperturbed atom.
The response of a hydrogen atom to a perturbative electric field is presented from a classical viewpoint. We find classical energy shifts in the hydrogen atom in situations that correspond to both the linear and quadratic Stark effects. We then compare these energy shifts to the exact quantum-mechanical values for the Stark effect. We find that the linear Stark effect can be accurately reproduced classically (given the correct initial conditions). In contrast, quantum-mechanical results for the quadratic Stark effect cannot be accurately reproduced classically, except in the correspondence principle limit of large principal quantum numbers n.