Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0807.1363 · Physical Review A

Beyond the quantum adiabatic approximation: Adiabatic perturbation theory

Gustavo Rigolin, Gerardo Ortíz, V. H. Ponce

Published Nov 18, 2008• 135 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We introduce a perturbative approach to solving the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation, named adiabatic perturbation theory (APT), whose zeroth-order term is the quantum adiabatic approximation. The small parameter in the power series expansion of the time-dependent wave function is the inverse of the time it takes to drive the system's Hamiltonian from the initial to its final form. We review other standard perturbative and nonperturbative ways of going beyond the adiabatic approximation, extending and finding exact relations among them, and also compare the efficiency of those methods against the APT. Most importantly, we determine APT corrections to the Berry phase by use of the Aharonov-Anandan geometric phase. We then solve several time-dependent problems, allowing us to illustrate that the APT is the only perturbative method that gives the right corrections to the adiabatic approximation. Finally, we propose an experiment to measure the APT corrections to the Berry phase and show, for a particular spin-$1∕2$ problem, that to first order in APT the geometric phase should be two and a half times the (adiabatic) Berry phase.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.78.052508

Related papers

Degenerate adiabatic perturbation theory: Foundations and applications

Gustavo Rigolin, Gerardo Ortíz

We present details and expand on the framework leading to the recently introduced degenerate adiabatic perturbation theory [Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 170406 (2010)], and on the formulation of the degenerate adiabatic theorem, along with its necessary and sufficient conditions [given in Phys. Rev. A 85, 062111 (2012)]. We start with the adiabatic approximation for degenerate Hamiltonians that paves the way to a clear and rigorous statement of the associated degenerate adiabatic theorem, where the non-Abelian geometric phase (Wilczek-Zee phase) plays a central role to its quantitative formulation. We then describe the degenerate adiabatic perturbation theory, whose zeroth-order term is the degenerate adiabatic approximation, in its full generality. The parameter in the perturbative power-series expansion of the time-dependent wave function is directly associated to the inverse of the time it takes to drive the system from its initial to its final state. With the aid of the degenerate adiabatic perturbation theory we obtain rigorous necessary and sufficient conditions for the validity of the adiabatic theorem of quantum mechanics. Finally, to illustrate the power and wide scope of the methodology, we apply the framework to a degenerate Hamiltonian, whose closed-form time-dependent wave function is derived exactly, and also to other nonexactly solvable Hamiltonians whose solutions are numerically computed.

arXiv:1403.6132•Physical Review A•Aug 6, 2014•23 citations

Quantum adiabatic approximation and the geometric phase

Ali Mostafazadeh

A precise definition of an adiabaticity parameter \ensuremath{\nu} of a time-dependent Hamiltonian is proposed. A variation of the time-dependent perturbation theory is presented which yields a series expansion of the evolution operator U(\ensuremath{\tau})=${\ensuremath{\sum}}_{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\ell}}}$${\mathrm{U}}^{(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\ell}})}$(\ensuremath{\tau}) with ${\mathrm{U}}^{(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\ell}})}$(\ensuremath{\tau}) being at least of the order ${\ensuremath{\nu}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\ell}}}$. In particular, ${\mathrm{U}}^{(0)}$(\ensuremath{\tau}) corresponds to the adiabatic approximation and yields Berry's adiabatic phase. It is shown that this series expansion has nothing to do with the 1/\ensuremath{\tau} expansion of U(\ensuremath{\tau}). It is also shown that the nonadiabatic part of the evolution operator is generated by a transformed Hamiltonian which is off-diagonal in the eigenbasis of the initial Hamiltonian. This suggests the introduction of an adiabatic product expansion for U(\ensuremath{\tau}) which turns out to yield exact expressions for U(\ensuremath{\tau}) for a large number of quantum systems. In particular, a simple application of the adiabatic product expansion is used to show that for the Hamiltonian describing the dynamics of a magnetic dipole in an arbitrarily changing magnetic field, there exists another Hamiltonian with the same eigenvectors for which the Schr\"odinger equation is exactly solvable. Some related issues concerning geometric phases and their physical significance are also discussed.

arXiv:hep-th/9606053•Physical Review A•Mar 1, 1997•59 citations

The Leading Order of the Theory of Strong Perturbations in Quantum Mechanics

Marco Frasca

We prove that, for a quantum system that undergoes a strong perturbation, the solution of the leading order equation of the strong field approximation (M.Frasca, Phys. Rev. A, {\bf 45}, 43 (1992)) can be derived by the adiabatic approximation. In fact, it is shown that greatest is the perturbation and more similar the quantum system is to an adiabatic one, the solution being written as a superposition of eigenstates of the time-dependent perturbation.A direct consequence of this result is that the solution of the Schrödinger equation in the interaction picture, in the same approximation for the perturbation, coincides with the one of the leading order of the strong field approximation. The limitation due to the requirement that the perturbation has to commute at different times is so overcome. Computational difficulties could arise to go to higher orders. Beside, the method is not useful for perturbations that are constant in time. In such a case a small time series is obtained, indicating that this approximation is just an application to quantum mechanics of the Kirkwood-Wigner expansion of statistical mechanics. The theory obtained in this way is applied to a time-dependent two-level spin model, already considered for the study of the Berry's phase, showing that a geometrical phase could arise if a part of the hamiltonian is considered as a strong perturbation. No adiabatic approximation is taken on the parameters of the hamiltonian, while their cyclicity is retained.

arXiv:quant-ph/9507007•Jul 12, 1995•1 citation

Perturbative approach to the adiabatic approximation

R. MacKenzie, Étienne Marcotte, H. Paquette

A new and intuitive perturbative approach to time-dependent quantum mechanics problems is presented, which is useful in situations where the evolution of the Hamiltonian is slow. The state of a system which starts in an instantaneous eigenstate of the initial Hamiltonian is written as a power series which has a straightforward diagrammatic representation. Each term of the series corresponds to a sequence of ``adiabatic'' evolutions, during which the system remains in an instantaneous eigenstate of the Hamiltonian, punctuated by transitions from one state to another. The first term of this series is the standard adiabatic evolution, the next is the well known first correction to it, and subsequent terms can be written down essentially by inspection. Although the final result is perhaps not terribly surprising, it seems to not be widely known, and the interpretation is new, as far as we know. Application of the method to the adiabatic approximation is given, and some discussion of the validity of this approximation is presented.

arXiv:quant-ph/0510024•Physical Review A•Apr 14, 2006•48 citations

Estudo comparativo entre duas teorias de perturbação dependentes do tempo em mecânica quântica

Diogo Henrique Garcia Lima

This monograph shows two perturbative methods to determine the time evolution of quantum systems described by time-depependent Hamiltonians. One method is the standard time-dependent perturbation theory usually found in text books of quantum mechanics. The other method is the adiabatic perturbation theory, whose perturbative corrections are obtained from the quantum adiabatic approximation. To compare the efficiency of those methods we apply them to two time-dependent problems. One is the Landau- Zener problem, whose time dependency is linear on time. We also show three analytical solutions to this problem. The other problem is a Hamiltonian which has a cyclic perturbation, whose numerical solution is employed to compare the efficacy of both perturbative \nmethods. The comparison between the two perturbation theories is based on the graphics of transition probability and of the fidelity, where all quantities are computed using the perturbative methods and the exact solutions to the problems. We conclude that the adiabatic perturbation theory improves the adiabatic approximation, is better than the standard theory when we deal with the limited Hamiltonian, and is relatively better than the standard theory for the Landau-Zener model.

•Feb 25, 2016•0 citations

Common quantum mechanics and statistical mechanics results

Douglas Natelson

A review of perturbation theory Most quantum mechanics problems are not solvable in closed form with analytical techniques. To extend our repertoire beyond just particle-in-a-box, a number of approximation techniques have been developed. A large class of these fall under the heading of “perturbation theory”, in which we consider our system to obey Hamiltonian H that may be written as H = H 0 + λ H 1 + λ 2 H 2 + … , (A.1) where H 0 is an exactly solvable Hamiltonian, λ is a small parameter, and the other terms may therefore be taken as small corrections. These notes are a quick review of how to deal with systems that obey such Hamiltonians. We'll be using Dirac notation and the Schrödinger formalism, in which the states are time-dependent. We begin with time-independent perturbation theory, and will then move on to consider time-dependent problems. For now, we'll only deal with single-particle problems, too. Time-independent We're going to use the time-independent Schrödinger equation, and look for the energy eigenvalues and eigenstates of H . First, suppose that our unperturbed problem, H 0 |ψ 0 〉 = E 0 |ψ 0 〉 (A.2) may be solved exactly, giving an energy eigenvalue spectrum E 0 j with corresponding eigenstates |ψ 0 j 〉. Remember, because H 0 is a Hermitian operator, its eigenvalues are real, and its eigenvectors |ψ 0 j 〉 form a complete set. The strategy we're going to take is straightforward. We're going to assume that our perturbative corrections to the Hamiltonian, λ H 1 + λ 2 H 2 + … , lead to corresponding perturbative corrections to the eigenvalues and eigenstates. That is, E j = E 0 j + λ E 1 j + λ 2 E 2 j + … , |ψ j 〉 = |ψ 0 j 〉 + λ|ψ 1 j 〉 + λ 2 |ψ 2 j 〉 + ….

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jun 18, 2015•0 citations
We introduce a perturbative approach to solving the time-dependent Schr"odinger equation, named adiabatic perturbation theory (APT), whose zeroth-order term is the quantum adiabatic approximation. The small parameter in the power series expansion of the time-dependent wave function is the inverse of the time it takes to drive the system's Hamiltonian from the initial to its final form. We review other standard perturbative and nonperturbative ways of going beyond the adiabatic approximation, extending and finding exact relations among them, and also compare the efficiency of those methods against the APT. Most importantly, we determine APT corrections to the Berry phase by use of the Aharonov-Anandan geometric phase. We then solve several time-dependent problems, allowing us to illustrate that the APT is the only perturbative method that gives the right corrections to the adiabatic approximation. Finally, we propose an experiment to measure the APT corrections to the Berry phase and show, for a particular spin-1∕21∕21∕2 problem, that to first order in APT the geometric phase should be two and a half times the (adiabatic) Berry phase.
We present details and expand on the framework leading to the recently introduced degenerate adiabatic perturbation theory [Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 170406 (2010)], and on the formulation of the degenerate adiabatic theorem, along with its necessary and sufficient conditions [given in Phys. Rev. A 85, 062111 (2012)]. We start with the adiabatic approximation for degenerate Hamiltonians that paves the way to a clear and rigorous statement of the associated degenerate adiabatic theorem, where the non-Abelian geometric phase (Wilczek-Zee phase) plays a central role to its quantitative formulation. We then describe the degenerate adiabatic perturbation theory, whose zeroth-order term is the degenerate adiabatic approximation, in its full generality. The parameter in the perturbative power-series expansion of the time-dependent wave function is directly associated to the inverse of the time it takes to drive the system from its initial to its final state. With the aid of the degenerate adiabatic perturbation theory we obtain rigorous necessary and sufficient conditions for the validity of the adiabatic theorem of quantum mechanics. Finally, to illustrate the power and wide scope of the methodology, we apply the framework to a degenerate Hamiltonian, whose closed-form time-dependent wave function is derived exactly, and also to other nonexactly solvable Hamiltonians whose solutions are numerically computed.
A precise definition of an adiabaticity parameter \ensuremath{\nu} of a time-dependent Hamiltonian is proposed. A variation of the time-dependent perturbation theory is presented which yields a series expansion of the evolution operator U(\ensuremath{\tau})=${\ensuremath{\sum}}_{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\ell}}}$${\mathrm{U}}^{(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\ell}})}$(\ensuremath{\tau}) with ${\mathrm{U}}^{(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\ell}})}$(\ensuremath{\tau}) being at least of the order ${\ensuremath{\nu}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\ell}}}$. In particular, U(0){\mathrm{U}}^{(0)}U(0)(\ensuremath{\tau}) corresponds to the adiabatic approximation and yields Berry's adiabatic phase. It is shown that this series expansion has nothing to do with the 1/\ensuremath{\tau} expansion of U(\ensuremath{\tau}). It is also shown that the nonadiabatic part of the evolution operator is generated by a transformed Hamiltonian which is off-diagonal in the eigenbasis of the initial Hamiltonian. This suggests the introduction of an adiabatic product expansion for U(\ensuremath{\tau}) which turns out to yield exact expressions for U(\ensuremath{\tau}) for a large number of quantum systems. In particular, a simple application of the adiabatic product expansion is used to show that for the Hamiltonian describing the dynamics of a magnetic dipole in an arbitrarily changing magnetic field, there exists another Hamiltonian with the same eigenvectors for which the Schr\"odinger equation is exactly solvable. Some related issues concerning geometric phases and their physical significance are also discussed.
We prove that, for a quantum system that undergoes a strong perturbation, the solution of the leading order equation of the strong field approximation (M.Frasca, Phys. Rev. A, {\bf 45}, 43 (1992)) can be derived by the adiabatic approximation. In fact, it is shown that greatest is the perturbation and more similar the quantum system is to an adiabatic one, the solution being written as a superposition of eigenstates of the time-dependent perturbation.A direct consequence of this result is that the solution of the Schrödinger equation in the interaction picture, in the same approximation for the perturbation, coincides with the one of the leading order of the strong field approximation. The limitation due to the requirement that the perturbation has to commute at different times is so overcome. Computational difficulties could arise to go to higher orders. Beside, the method is not useful for perturbations that are constant in time. In such a case a small time series is obtained, indicating that this approximation is just an application to quantum mechanics of the Kirkwood-Wigner expansion of statistical mechanics. The theory obtained in this way is applied to a time-dependent two-level spin model, already considered for the study of the Berry's phase, showing that a geometrical phase could arise if a part of the hamiltonian is considered as a strong perturbation. No adiabatic approximation is taken on the parameters of the hamiltonian, while their cyclicity is retained.
A new and intuitive perturbative approach to time-dependent quantum mechanics problems is presented, which is useful in situations where the evolution of the Hamiltonian is slow. The state of a system which starts in an instantaneous eigenstate of the initial Hamiltonian is written as a power series which has a straightforward diagrammatic representation. Each term of the series corresponds to a sequence of ``adiabatic'' evolutions, during which the system remains in an instantaneous eigenstate of the Hamiltonian, punctuated by transitions from one state to another. The first term of this series is the standard adiabatic evolution, the next is the well known first correction to it, and subsequent terms can be written down essentially by inspection. Although the final result is perhaps not terribly surprising, it seems to not be widely known, and the interpretation is new, as far as we know. Application of the method to the adiabatic approximation is given, and some discussion of the validity of this approximation is presented.
This monograph shows two perturbative methods to determine the time evolution of quantum systems described by time-depependent Hamiltonians. One method is the standard time-dependent perturbation theory usually found in text books of quantum mechanics. The other method is the adiabatic perturbation theory, whose perturbative corrections are obtained from the quantum adiabatic approximation. To compare the efficiency of those methods we apply them to two time-dependent problems. One is the Landau- Zener problem, whose time dependency is linear on time. We also show three analytical solutions to this problem. The other problem is a Hamiltonian which has a cyclic perturbation, whose numerical solution is employed to compare the efficacy of both perturbative \nmethods. The comparison between the two perturbation theories is based on the graphics of transition probability and of the fidelity, where all quantities are computed using the perturbative methods and the exact solutions to the problems. We conclude that the adiabatic perturbation theory improves the adiabatic approximation, is better than the standard theory when we deal with the limited Hamiltonian, and is relatively better than the standard theory for the Landau-Zener model.
A review of perturbation theory Most quantum mechanics problems are not solvable in closed form with analytical techniques. To extend our repertoire beyond just particle-in-a-box, a number of approximation techniques have been developed. A large class of these fall under the heading of “perturbation theory”, in which we consider our system to obey Hamiltonian H that may be written as H = H 0 + λ H 1 + λ 2 H 2 + … , (A.1) where H 0 is an exactly solvable Hamiltonian, λ is a small parameter, and the other terms may therefore be taken as small corrections. These notes are a quick review of how to deal with systems that obey such Hamiltonians. We'll be using Dirac notation and the Schrödinger formalism, in which the states are time-dependent. We begin with time-independent perturbation theory, and will then move on to consider time-dependent problems. For now, we'll only deal with single-particle problems, too. Time-independent We're going to use the time-independent Schrödinger equation, and look for the energy eigenvalues and eigenstates of H . First, suppose that our unperturbed problem, H 0 |ψ 0 〉 = E 0 |ψ 0 〉 (A.2) may be solved exactly, giving an energy eigenvalue spectrum E 0 j with corresponding eigenstates |ψ 0 j 〉. Remember, because H 0 is a Hermitian operator, its eigenvalues are real, and its eigenvectors |ψ 0 j 〉 form a complete set. The strategy we're going to take is straightforward. We're going to assume that our perturbative corrections to the Hamiltonian, λ H 1 + λ 2 H 2 + … , lead to corresponding perturbative corrections to the eigenvalues and eigenstates. That is, E j = E 0 j + λ E 1 j + λ 2 E 2 j + … , |ψ j 〉 = |ψ 0 j 〉 + λ|ψ 1 j 〉 + λ 2 |ψ 2 j 〉 + ….