Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0807.1338 · IEEE Transactions on Information Theory

The Operational Meaning of Min- and Max-Entropy

Robert König, Renato Renner, Christian Schaffner

Published Aug 24, 2009• 697 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper, we show that the conditional min-entropyHmin(A|B) of a bipartite staterhoABis directly related to the maximum achievable overlap with a maximally entangled state if only local actions on theB-part ofrhoABare allowed. In the special case whereAis classical, this overlap corresponds to the probability of guessingAgivenB. In a similar vein, we connect the conditional max-entropyHmax(A|B) to the maximum fidelity ofrhoABwith a product state that is completely mixed onA. In the case whereAis classical, this corresponds to the security ofAwhen used as a secret key in the presence of an adversary holdingB. Because min- and max-entropies are known to characterize information-processing tasks such as randomness extraction and state merging, our results establish a direct connection between these tasks and basic operational problems. For example, they imply that the (logarithm of the) probability of guessingAgivenBis a lower bound on the number of uniform secret bits that can be extracted fromArelative to an adversary holdingB.

DOI
10.1109/tit.2009.2025545

Related papers

Accessible Quantum Correlations Under Complexity Constraints

Álvaro Yángüez, Noam Avidan, Jan Kochanowski +1 more

Quantum systems may contain underlying correlations which are inaccessible to computationally bounded observers. We capture this distinction through a framework that analyses bipartite states only using efficiently implementable quantum channels. This leads to a complexity-constrained max-divergence and a corresponding computational min-entropy. The latter quantity recovers the standard operational meaning of the conditional min-entropy: in the fully quantum case, it quantifies the largest overlap with a maximally entangled state attainable via efficient operations on the conditional subsystem. For classical-quantum states, it further reduces to the optimal guessing probability of a computationally bounded observer with access to side information. Lastly, in the absence of side information, the computational min-entropy simplifies to a computational notion of the operator norm. We then establish strong separations between the information-theoretic and complexity-constrained notions of min-entropy. For pure states, there exist highly entangled families of states with extremal min-entropy whose efficiently accessible entanglement in terms of computational min-entropy is exponentially suppressed. For mixed states, the separation is even sharper: the information-theoretic conditional min-entropy can be highly negative while the complexity-constrained quantity remains nearly maximal. Under the cryptographic Learning with Errors hardness assumption, we construct efficiently preparable states exhibiting both separations, even when their preparation circuits are fully known. Overall, our results demonstrate that computational constraints can fundamentally limit the quantum correlations that are observable in practice.

quant-pharXiv:2604.15540•Apr 20, 2026•1 citation

Accessible Quantum Correlations Under Complexity Constraints

Álvaro Yángüez, Noam Avidan, Jan Kochanowski +1 more

Quantum systems may contain underlying correlations which are inaccessible to computationally bounded observers. We capture this distinction through a framework that analyses bipartite states only using efficiently implementable quantum channels. This leads to a complexity-constrained max-divergence and a corresponding computational min-entropy. The latter quantity recovers the standard operational meaning of the conditional min-entropy: in the fully quantum case, it quantifies the largest overlap with a maximally entangled state attainable via efficient operations on the conditional subsystem. For classical-quantum states, it further reduces to the optimal guessing probability of a computationally bounded observer with access to side information. Lastly, in the absence of side information, the computational min-entropy simplifies to a computational notion of the operator norm. We then establish strong separations between the information-theoretic and complexity-constrained notions of min-entropy. For pure states, there exist highly entangled families of states with extremal min-entropy whose efficiently accessible entanglement in terms of computational min-entropy is exponentially suppressed. For mixed states, the separation is even sharper: the information-theoretic conditional min-entropy can be highly negative while the complexity-constrained quantity remains nearly maximal. Overall, our results demonstrate that computational constraints can fundamentally limit the quantum correlations that are observable in practice.

•Sep 28, 2026•0 citations

Entanglement Sampling and Applications

Frédéric Dupuis, Omar Fawzi, Stephanie Wehner

A natural measure for the amount of quantum information that a physical system E holds about another system A = A1, .. . , Anis given by the min-entropy Hmin(A|E). In particular, the min-entropy measures the amount of entanglement between E and A, and is the relevant measure when analyzing a wide variety of problems ranging from randomness extraction in quantum cryptography, decoupling used in channel coding, to physical processes such as thermalization or the thermodynamic work cost (or gain) of erasing a quantum system. As such, it is a central question to determine the behavior of the minentropy after some process M. is applied to the system A. Here, we introduce a new generic tool relating the resulting min-entropy to the original one, and apply it to several settings of interest. A simple example of such a process is the one of sampling, where a subset S of the systems A1, ... , An is selected at random. Our tool allows us to quantify the entanglement that E has with the selected systems AS, i.e., Hmin(AS|ES) as a function of the original Hmin(A|E). We give two applications of this result. First, it directly provides the first local quantum-to-classical randomness extractors for use in quantum cryptography, as well as decoupling operations acting on only a small fraction AS of the input A. Moreover, it gives lower bounds on the dimension of k-out-of-n fully quantum random access encodings. Another natural example of such a process is a measurement in, e.g., BB84 bases commonly used in quantum cryptography. We establish the first entropic uncertainty relations with quantum side information that are nontrivial whenever E is not maximally entangled with A. As a consequence, we are able to prove optimality of quantum cryptographic schemes in the noisy-storage model. This model allows for the secure implementation of two-party cryptographic primitives under the assumption that the adversary cannot store quantum information perfectly. A special case is the bounded-quantum-storage model (BQSM), which assumes that the adversary's quantum memory device is noise free but limited in size. Ever since the inception of the BQSM, it has been a vexing open question to determine whether the security is possible as long as the adversary can only.

arXiv:1305.1316•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Nov 26, 2014•98 citations

Duality Between Smooth Min- and Max-Entropies

Marco Tomamichel, Roger Colbeck, Renato Renner

In classical and quantum information theory, operational quantities such as the amount of randomness that can be extracted from a given source or the amount of space needed to store given data are normally characterized by one of two entropy measures, called smooth min-entropy and smooth max-entropy, respectively. While both entropies are equal to the von Neumann entropy in certain special cases (e.g., asymptotically, for many independent repetitions of the given data), their values can differ arbitrarily in the general case. In this paper, a recently discovered duality relation between (nonsmooth) min- and max-entropies is extended to the smooth case. More precisely, it is shown that the smooth min-entropy of a systemAconditioned on a systemBequals the negative of the smooth max-entropy ofAconditioned on a purifying systemC. This result immediately implies that certain operational quantities (such as the amount of compression and the amount of randomness that can be extracted from given data) are related. We explain how such relations have applications in cryptographic security proofs.

arXiv:0907.5238•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Aug 19, 2010•252 citations

The Trivial Bound of Entropic Uncertainty Relations

Minu J. Bae

Entropic uncertainty relations are underpinning to compute the quantitative security bound in quantum cryptographic applications, such as quantum random number generation (QRNG) and quantum key distribution (QKD). All security proofs derive a relation between the information accessible to the legitimate group and the maximum knowledge that an adversary may have gained, Eve, which exploits entropic uncertainty relations to lower bound Eve's uncertainty about the raw key generated by one party, Alice. The standard entropic uncertainty relations is to utilize the smooth min- and max-entropies to show these cryptographic applications' security by computing the overlap of two incompatible measurements or positive-operator valued measures (POVMs). This paper draws one case of the POVM-versioned standard entropic uncertainty relation yielding the trivial bound since the maximum overlap in POVMs always produces the trivial value, "one." So, it fails to tie the smooth min-entropy to show the security of the quantum cryptographic application.

arXiv:2208.00242•Jul 30, 2022•0 citations

Comparison of Quantum Channels by Superchannels

Gilad Gour

We extend the definition of the conditional min-entropy from bipartite quantum states to bipartite quantum channels. We show that many of the properties of the conditional min-entropy carry over to the extended version, including an operational interpretation as a guessing probability when one of the subsystems is classical. We then show that the extended conditional min-entropy can be used to fully characterize when two bipartite quantum channels are related to each other via a superchannel (also known as supermap or a comb) that is acting on one of the subsystems. This relation is a pre-order that extends the definition of “quantum majorization” from bipartite states to bipartite channels, and can also be characterized with semidefinite programming. As a special case, our characterization provides necessary and sufficient conditions for when a set of quantum channels is related to another set of channels via a single superchannel. We discuss the applications of our results to channel discrimination, and to resource theories of quantum processes. Along the way we study channel divergences, entropy functions of quantum channels, and noise models of superchannels, including random unitary superchannels and doubly-stochastic superchannels. For the latter we give a physical meaning as being completely-uniformity preserving.

arXiv:1808.02607•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Apr 1, 2019•147 citations
In this paper, we show that the conditional min-entropyHmin(A|B) of a bipartite staterhoABis directly related to the maximum achievable overlap with a maximally entangled state if only local actions on theB-part ofrhoABare allowed. In the special case whereAis classical, this overlap corresponds to the probability of guessingAgivenB. In a similar vein, we connect the conditional max-entropyHmax(A|B) to the maximum fidelity ofrhoABwith a product state that is completely mixed onA. In the case whereAis classical, this corresponds to the security ofAwhen used as a secret key in the presence of an adversary holdingB. Because min- and max-entropies are known to characterize information-processing tasks such as randomness extraction and state merging, our results establish a direct connection between these tasks and basic operational problems. For example, they imply that the (logarithm of the) probability of guessingAgivenBis a lower bound on the number of uniform secret bits that can be extracted fromArelative to an adversary holdingB.
Quantum systems may contain underlying correlations which are inaccessible to computationally bounded observers. We capture this distinction through a framework that analyses bipartite states only using efficiently implementable quantum channels. This leads to a complexity-constrained max-divergence and a corresponding computational min-entropy. The latter quantity recovers the standard operational meaning of the conditional min-entropy: in the fully quantum case, it quantifies the largest overlap with a maximally entangled state attainable via efficient operations on the conditional subsystem. For classical-quantum states, it further reduces to the optimal guessing probability of a computationally bounded observer with access to side information. Lastly, in the absence of side information, the computational min-entropy simplifies to a computational notion of the operator norm. We then establish strong separations between the information-theoretic and complexity-constrained notions of min-entropy. For pure states, there exist highly entangled families of states with extremal min-entropy whose efficiently accessible entanglement in terms of computational min-entropy is exponentially suppressed. For mixed states, the separation is even sharper: the information-theoretic conditional min-entropy can be highly negative while the complexity-constrained quantity remains nearly maximal. Under the cryptographic Learning with Errors hardness assumption, we construct efficiently preparable states exhibiting both separations, even when their preparation circuits are fully known. Overall, our results demonstrate that computational constraints can fundamentally limit the quantum correlations that are observable in practice.
Quantum systems may contain underlying correlations which are inaccessible to computationally bounded observers. We capture this distinction through a framework that analyses bipartite states only using efficiently implementable quantum channels. This leads to a complexity-constrained max-divergence and a corresponding computational min-entropy. The latter quantity recovers the standard operational meaning of the conditional min-entropy: in the fully quantum case, it quantifies the largest overlap with a maximally entangled state attainable via efficient operations on the conditional subsystem. For classical-quantum states, it further reduces to the optimal guessing probability of a computationally bounded observer with access to side information. Lastly, in the absence of side information, the computational min-entropy simplifies to a computational notion of the operator norm. We then establish strong separations between the information-theoretic and complexity-constrained notions of min-entropy. For pure states, there exist highly entangled families of states with extremal min-entropy whose efficiently accessible entanglement in terms of computational min-entropy is exponentially suppressed. For mixed states, the separation is even sharper: the information-theoretic conditional min-entropy can be highly negative while the complexity-constrained quantity remains nearly maximal. Overall, our results demonstrate that computational constraints can fundamentally limit the quantum correlations that are observable in practice.
A natural measure for the amount of quantum information that a physical system E holds about another system A = A1, .. . , Anis given by the min-entropy Hmin(A|E). In particular, the min-entropy measures the amount of entanglement between E and A, and is the relevant measure when analyzing a wide variety of problems ranging from randomness extraction in quantum cryptography, decoupling used in channel coding, to physical processes such as thermalization or the thermodynamic work cost (or gain) of erasing a quantum system. As such, it is a central question to determine the behavior of the minentropy after some process M. is applied to the system A. Here, we introduce a new generic tool relating the resulting min-entropy to the original one, and apply it to several settings of interest. A simple example of such a process is the one of sampling, where a subset S of the systems A1, ... , An is selected at random. Our tool allows us to quantify the entanglement that E has with the selected systems AS, i.e., Hmin(AS|ES) as a function of the original Hmin(A|E). We give two applications of this result. First, it directly provides the first local quantum-to-classical randomness extractors for use in quantum cryptography, as well as decoupling operations acting on only a small fraction AS of the input A. Moreover, it gives lower bounds on the dimension of k-out-of-n fully quantum random access encodings. Another natural example of such a process is a measurement in, e.g., BB84 bases commonly used in quantum cryptography. We establish the first entropic uncertainty relations with quantum side information that are nontrivial whenever E is not maximally entangled with A. As a consequence, we are able to prove optimality of quantum cryptographic schemes in the noisy-storage model. This model allows for the secure implementation of two-party cryptographic primitives under the assumption that the adversary cannot store quantum information perfectly. A special case is the bounded-quantum-storage model (BQSM), which assumes that the adversary's quantum memory device is noise free but limited in size. Ever since the inception of the BQSM, it has been a vexing open question to determine whether the security is possible as long as the adversary can only.
In classical and quantum information theory, operational quantities such as the amount of randomness that can be extracted from a given source or the amount of space needed to store given data are normally characterized by one of two entropy measures, called smooth min-entropy and smooth max-entropy, respectively. While both entropies are equal to the von Neumann entropy in certain special cases (e.g., asymptotically, for many independent repetitions of the given data), their values can differ arbitrarily in the general case. In this paper, a recently discovered duality relation between (nonsmooth) min- and max-entropies is extended to the smooth case. More precisely, it is shown that the smooth min-entropy of a systemAconditioned on a systemBequals the negative of the smooth max-entropy ofAconditioned on a purifying systemC. This result immediately implies that certain operational quantities (such as the amount of compression and the amount of randomness that can be extracted from given data) are related. We explain how such relations have applications in cryptographic security proofs.
Entropic uncertainty relations are underpinning to compute the quantitative security bound in quantum cryptographic applications, such as quantum random number generation (QRNG) and quantum key distribution (QKD). All security proofs derive a relation between the information accessible to the legitimate group and the maximum knowledge that an adversary may have gained, Eve, which exploits entropic uncertainty relations to lower bound Eve's uncertainty about the raw key generated by one party, Alice. The standard entropic uncertainty relations is to utilize the smooth min- and max-entropies to show these cryptographic applications' security by computing the overlap of two incompatible measurements or positive-operator valued measures (POVMs). This paper draws one case of the POVM-versioned standard entropic uncertainty relation yielding the trivial bound since the maximum overlap in POVMs always produces the trivial value, "one." So, it fails to tie the smooth min-entropy to show the security of the quantum cryptographic application.
We extend the definition of the conditional min-entropy from bipartite quantum states to bipartite quantum channels. We show that many of the properties of the conditional min-entropy carry over to the extended version, including an operational interpretation as a guessing probability when one of the subsystems is classical. We then show that the extended conditional min-entropy can be used to fully characterize when two bipartite quantum channels are related to each other via a superchannel (also known as supermap or a comb) that is acting on one of the subsystems. This relation is a pre-order that extends the definition of “quantum majorization” from bipartite states to bipartite channels, and can also be characterized with semidefinite programming. As a special case, our characterization provides necessary and sufficient conditions for when a set of quantum channels is related to another set of channels via a single superchannel. We discuss the applications of our results to channel discrimination, and to resource theories of quantum processes. Along the way we study channel divergences, entropy functions of quantum channels, and noise models of superchannels, including random unitary superchannels and doubly-stochastic superchannels. For the latter we give a physical meaning as being completely-uniformity preserving.