Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0806.0450 · Quantum Information and Computation

On perfect completeness for QMA

Scott Aaronson

Published Jan 1, 2009• 45 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Whether the class QMA (Quantum Merlin Arthur)\ is equal to QMA_1, or QMA with one-sided error, has been an open problem for years. This note helps to explain why the problem is difficult,\ by using ideas from real analysis to give a "quantum" relative to which QMA \neq QMA_1. As a byproduct, we find that there are facts about quantum complexity classes that are classically relativizing but not quantumly relativizing, among them such "trivial" containments as BQP \subseteq ZQEXP.

DOI
10.26421/qic9.1-2-5

Related papers

On Perfect Completeness for QMA

Scott Aaronson

Whether the class QMA (Quantum Merlin Arthur) is equal to QMA1, or QMA with onesided error, has been an open problem for years. This note helps to explain why the problem is difficult, by using ideas from real analysis to give a "quantum oracle" relative to which QMA ≠ QMA1. As a byproduct, we find that there are facts about quantum complexity classes that are classically relativizing but not quantumly relativizing, among them such "trivial" containments as BQP ⊆ ZQEXP.

•Jun 3, 2008•4 citations

QMA has perfect completeness

Sabee Grewal, Dorian Rudolph

We prove $\mathsf{QMA} = \mathsf{QMA_1}$, i.e., every quantum Merlin-Arthur proof system can be made perfectly complete. Our construction uses only Hadamard, Toffoli, and $X$ gates, yielding a universal gate set for $\mathsf{QMA_1}$. As a consequence, quantum $3$-SAT is $\mathsf{QMA}$-complete. The construction relativizes to classical oracles, so known classical-oracle separations of $\mathsf{QMA}$ from $\mathsf{QCMA}$ extend to $\mathsf{QMA_1}$.

quant-pharXiv:2609.13032•Sep 14, 2026•5 citations

The geometry of quantum computation

Mark R. Dowling, Michael A. Nielsen

Whether the class Quantum Merlin Arthur is equal to QMA_1, or QMA with one-sided error, has been an open problem for years. This note helps to explain why the problem is difficult, by using ideas from real analysis to give a quantum oracle relative to which QMA\neqQMA_1. As a byproduct, we find that there are facts about quantum complexity classes that are classically relativizing but not quantumly relativizing, among them such trivial containments as BQP\subseteq{ZQEXP}.

Quantum Information and Computation•Nov 1, 2008•148 citations

Quantum-Merlin-Arthur Problems Have Perfect Completeness with an Infinite Counter

Stacey Jeffery, Freek Witteveen

A longstanding open problem in quantum complexity theory is whether Quantum Merlin-Arthur (QMA), the quantum analog of nondeterministic polynomial time, is equal to QMA_{1}, its one-sided error variant. We show that QMA=QMA^{∞}=QMA_{1}^{∞}, where QMA_{1}^{∞} is like QMA_{1}, but the verifier has an infinite register, as part of their witness system, in which they can efficiently perform a shift (increment) operation. We call this register an "infinite counter," and compare it to a program counter in a Las Vegas algorithm. The result, QMA=QMA^{∞} means such an infinite register does not increase the power of QMA, but does imply perfect completeness. By truncating our construction to finite dimensions, we get a QMA-amplifier that only amplifies completeness, not soundness, but does so in significantly less time than previous QMA amplifiers. Our new construction achieves completeness 1-2^{-q} using O(1) calls to each of the original verifier and its inverse, and O(logq) other gates, proving that QMA has completeness doubly exponentially close to 1, i.e., QMA=QMA(1-2^{-2^{r}},2^{-r}) for any polynomial r.

Physical Review Letters•Apr 2, 2026•4 citations

Quantum Merlin-Arthur and Proofs Without Relative Phase

Roozbeh Bassirian, Bill Fefferman, Kunal Marwaha

We study a variant of QMA where quantum proofs have no relative phase (i.e. non-negative amplitudes, up to a global phase). If only completeness is modified, this class is equal to QMA [arXiv:1410.2882]; but if both completeness and soundness are modified, the class (named QMA+ by Jeronimo and Wu) can be much more powerful. We show that QMA+ with some constant gap is equal to NEXP, yet QMA+ with some *other* constant gap is equal to QMA. One interpretation is that Merlin's ability to "deceive" originates from relative phase at least as much as from entanglement, since QMA(2) $\subseteq$ NEXP.

arXiv:2306.13247•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jun 23, 2023•13 citations

NP vs QMA_\log(2)

Salman Beigi

Although it is believed unlikely that $\NP$-hard problems admit efficient quantum algorithms, it has been shown that a quantum verifier can solve NP-complete problems given a "short" quantum proof; more precisely, NP\subseteq QMA_{\log}(2) where QMA_{\log}(2) denotes the class of quantum Merlin-Arthur games in which there are two unentangled provers who send two logarithmic size quantum witnesses to the verifier. The inclusion NP\subseteq QMA_{\log}(2) has been proved by Blier and Tapp by stating a quantum Merlin-Arthur protocol for 3-coloring with perfect completeness and gap 1/24n^6. Moreover, Aaronson et al. have shown the above inclusion with a constant gap by considering $\widetilde{O}(\sqrt{n})$ witnesses of logarithmic size. However, we still do not know if QMA_{\log}(2) with a constant gap contains NP. In this paper, we show that 3-SAT admits a QMA_{\log}(2) protocol with the gap 1/n^{3+\epsilon}} for every constant \epsilon>0.

arXiv:0810.5109•Quantum Information and Computation•Jan 1, 2010•36 citations
Whether the class QMA (Quantum Merlin Arthur)\ is equal to QMA_1, or QMA with one-sided error, has been an open problem for years. This note helps to explain why the problem is difficult,\ by using ideas from real analysis to give a "quantum" relative to which QMA \neq QMA_1. As a byproduct, we find that there are facts about quantum complexity classes that are classically relativizing but not quantumly relativizing, among them such "trivial" containments as BQP \subseteq ZQEXP.
We prove QMA=QMA1\mathsf{QMA} = \mathsf{QMA_1}QMA=QMA1​, i.e., every quantum Merlin-Arthur proof system can be made perfectly complete. Our construction uses only Hadamard, Toffoli, and XXX gates, yielding a universal gate set for QMA1\mathsf{QMA_1}QMA1​. As a consequence, quantum 333-SAT is QMA\mathsf{QMA}QMA-complete. The construction relativizes to classical oracles, so known classical-oracle separations of QMA\mathsf{QMA}QMA from QCMA\mathsf{QCMA}QCMA extend to QMA1\mathsf{QMA_1}QMA1​.
A longstanding open problem in quantum complexity theory is whether Quantum Merlin-Arthur (QMA), the quantum analog of nondeterministic polynomial time, is equal to QMA_{1}, its one-sided error variant. We show that QMA=QMA^{∞}=QMA_{1}^{∞}, where QMA_{1}^{∞} is like QMA_{1}, but the verifier has an infinite register, as part of their witness system, in which they can efficiently perform a shift (increment) operation. We call this register an "infinite counter," and compare it to a program counter in a Las Vegas algorithm. The result, QMA=QMA^{∞} means such an infinite register does not increase the power of QMA, but does imply perfect completeness. By truncating our construction to finite dimensions, we get a QMA-amplifier that only amplifies completeness, not soundness, but does so in significantly less time than previous QMA amplifiers. Our new construction achieves completeness 1-2^{-q} using O(1) calls to each of the original verifier and its inverse, and O(logq) other gates, proving that QMA has completeness doubly exponentially close to 1, i.e., QMA=QMA(1-2^{-2^{r}},2^{-r}) for any polynomial r.
We study a variant of QMA where quantum proofs have no relative phase (i.e. non-negative amplitudes, up to a global phase). If only completeness is modified, this class is equal to QMA [arXiv:1410.2882]; but if both completeness and soundness are modified, the class (named QMA+ by Jeronimo and Wu) can be much more powerful. We show that QMA+ with some constant gap is equal to NEXP, yet QMA+ with some *other* constant gap is equal to QMA. One interpretation is that Merlin's ability to "deceive" originates from relative phase at least as much as from entanglement, since QMA(2) ⊆\subseteq⊆ NEXP.
Although it is believed unlikely that $\NP$-hard problems admit efficient quantum algorithms, it has been shown that a quantum verifier can solve NP-complete problems given a "short" quantum proof; more precisely, NP\subseteq QMA_{\log}(2) where QMA_{\log}(2) denotes the class of quantum Merlin-Arthur games in which there are two unentangled provers who send two logarithmic size quantum witnesses to the verifier. The inclusion NP\subseteq QMA_{\log}(2) has been proved by Blier and Tapp by stating a quantum Merlin-Arthur protocol for 3-coloring with perfect completeness and gap 1/24n^6. Moreover, Aaronson et al. have shown the above inclusion with a constant gap by considering O~(n)\widetilde{O}(\sqrt{n})O(n​) witnesses of logarithmic size. However, we still do not know if QMA_{\log}(2) with a constant gap contains NP. In this paper, we show that 3-SAT admits a QMA_{\log}(2) protocol with the gap 1/n^{3+\epsilon}} for every constant \epsilon>0.