Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0805.2177 · Physical Review Letters

Local Interactions and Non-Abelian Quantum Loop Gases

Matthias Troyer, Simon Trebst, Kirill Shtengel, Chetan Nayak

Published Dec 2, 2008• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Two-dimensional quantum loop gases are elementary examples of topological ground states with Abelian or non-Abelian anyonic excitations. While Abelian loop gases appear as ground states of local, gapped Hamiltonians such as the toric code, we show that gapped non-Abelian loop gases require nonlocal interactions (or nontrivial inner products). Perturbing a local, gapless Hamiltonian with an anticipated "non-Abelian" ground-state wave function immediately drives the system into the Abelian phase, as can be seen by measuring the Hausdorff dimension of loops. Local quantum critical behavior is found in a loop gas in which all equal-time correlations of local operators decay exponentially.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.101.230401

Related papers

Quantum loop models and the non-abelian toric code

Paul Fendley

I define quantum loop models whose degrees of freedom are Ising spins on the square lattice as in the toric code, but where the excitations should have non-abelian statistics. The inner product is topological, allowing a direct implementation of the anyonic fusion matrix on the lattice. It also makes deconfined anyons possible for a variety of values of the weight per loop $d$ in the ground state. For d=\sqrt{2}, a gapped non-abelian topological phase can occur with only four-spin interactions.

arXiv:0711.0014•Nov 1, 2007•9 citations

Merging quantum loop gases: A route to non-Abelian topological phases

Belén Paredes

Condensation of quantum loops naturally leads to topological phases with Abelian excitations. Here, I propose that non-Abelian topological phases can arise from merging two (or several) identical Abelian quantum loop condensates. I define merging through a symmetrization operation, which makes the two loop condensates indistinguishable, inducing the possibility of a topological degeneracy in the space of quasiparticles. To illustrate the construction, the case of two identical toric-code quantum loop gases is considered. A spin-1 model for the two-dimensional square lattice is presented for which the resulting merged state is the exact unique ground state. This Hamiltonian involves four-body interactions between spins located at the same plaquette or vertex, which are quadratic in the spin-1 operators. Vertex and plaquette interaction terms are not mutually commuting. The model displays gapped excitations that result from merging anyons in both toric-code copies. These excitations exhibit non-Abelian braiding properties.

arXiv:1209.6040•Physical Review B•Oct 11, 2012•3 citations

Gapped Parent Hamiltonians for the Strongly Deformed Toric Code

Nandagopal Manoj, Zack Weinstein, Jason Alicea

Local non-unitary deformations of topologically ordered wavefunctions can drive transitions into peculiar states that challenge modern perspectives on gapped quantum matter. The strongly deformed toric code offers a curious case, hosting $m$ anyon condensation alongside perimeter-law scaling of Wilson loops charged under an exact 1-form symmetry---properties that typically do not coexist in gapped ground states. Nevertheless, we rigorously construct local gapped parent Hamiltonians for these strongly deformed toric code states. The Hamiltonians we construct are not strictly finite-range, but contain sums of Wilson loop operators whose coefficients decay exponentially in their diameter. If one adopts standard locality bounds used to define gapped phases---which allow for such exponentially decaying terms---our construction shows that these states realize a trivial gapped phase. Within this locality class, we demonstrate that perimeter-law scaling of Wilson loops does not imply a spontaneously broken 1-form symmetry, and from a dual perspective, that long-range ferromagnetic order and perimeter-law disorder parameter correlations can coexist in a 2D gapped ground state. We evade a recent no-go theorem [Sahay et al., arXiv:2503.01977] by relaxing its assumptions in a manner that we quantify as benign in the thermodynamic limit. More broadly, our results highlight that stronger notions of locality are necessary for prohibiting these counterintuitive properties within a gapped phase.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2607.28740•Aug 3, 2026•0 citations

String-nets, single- and double-stranded quantum loop gases for non-Abelian anyons

Andrea Velenich, Claudio Chamon, Xiao-Gang Wen

String-net condensation can give rise to non-Abelian anyons whereas loop condensation usually gives rise to Abelian anyons. It has been proposed that generalized quantum loop gases with non-orthogonal inner products can produce non-Abelian anyons. We detail an exact mapping between the string-net and the generalized loop models and explain how the non-orthogonal products arise. We also introduce a loop model of double-stranded nets where quantum loops with an orthogonal inner product and local interactions supports non-Abelian Fibonacci anyons. Finally we emphasize the origin of the sign problem in such systems and its consequences on the complexity of their ground state wave functions.

arXiv:0911.1132•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Apr 13, 2010•3 citations

Enforced Gaplessness from States with Exponentially Decaying Correlations

Rahul Sahay, Curt W. von Keyserlingk, Ruben Verresen +1 more

It is well known that an exponentially localized Hamiltonian must be gapless if its ground state has algebraic correlations. We show that even certain exponentially decaying correlations can imply gaplessness. This is exemplified by the deformed toric code $\propto \exp(β\sum_{\ell} Z_{\ell}) |\mathsf{TC}\rangle$, where $|\mathsf{TC}\rangle$ is a fixed-point toric code wavefunction. Although it has a confined regime for $β> β_c$, recent work has drawn attention to its perimeter law loop correlations. Here, we show that these unusual loop correlations -- namely, perimeter law coexisting with a 1-form symmetry whose disorder operator has long-range order -- imply that any local parent Hamiltonian must either be gapless or have a degeneracy scaling with system size. Moreover, we construct a variational low-energy state for arbitrary local frustration-free Hamiltonians, upper bounding the finite-size gap by $O(1/L^3)$ on periodic boundary conditions. Strikingly, these variational states look like loop waves -- non-quasiparticle analogs of spin waves -- generated from the ground state by non-local loop operators. Our findings have implications for identifying the subset of Hilbert space to which gapped ground states belong, and the techniques have wide applicability. For instance, a corollary of our first result is that Glauber dynamics for the ordered phase of the two-dimensional classical Ising model on the torus must have a gapless Markov transition matrix, with our second result bounding its gap.

arXiv:2503.01977•Mar 3, 2025•10 citations

Toric Code for Pedestrians

We study a quantum spin liquid called Kitaev’s toric code, which exhibits topological order [4-6]. This system is attractive since many of its properties can be analytically explored. As in the BCS and fractional quantum Hall cases, one first guesses the correct trial wave function for the ground state and then constructs quasiparticle excitations. In the toric code, some of these excitations exhibit Abelian anyon (semion) statistics. The topological entanglement entropy of this phase is finite, equal to ln 2. Moreover, the ground state is four-fold degenerate in a torus topology. (Note that the Laughlin state at filling factor 1/3 has degeneracy 3 and the superconducting state has degeneracy 4.) Some of these properties of the toric code, especially the appearance of a pair of non-local excitations, are similar to those of interacting disordered zigzag nanoribbons and the reader is encouraged to study this chapter carefully. The presentation of this chapter is somewhat heuristic. For a more refined treatment, see, for example Refs. [2, 3].

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Apr 1, 2023•0 citations
Two-dimensional quantum loop gases are elementary examples of topological ground states with Abelian or non-Abelian anyonic excitations. While Abelian loop gases appear as ground states of local, gapped Hamiltonians such as the toric code, we show that gapped non-Abelian loop gases require nonlocal interactions (or nontrivial inner products). Perturbing a local, gapless Hamiltonian with an anticipated "non-Abelian" ground-state wave function immediately drives the system into the Abelian phase, as can be seen by measuring the Hausdorff dimension of loops. Local quantum critical behavior is found in a loop gas in which all equal-time correlations of local operators decay exponentially.
I define quantum loop models whose degrees of freedom are Ising spins on the square lattice as in the toric code, but where the excitations should have non-abelian statistics. The inner product is topological, allowing a direct implementation of the anyonic fusion matrix on the lattice. It also makes deconfined anyons possible for a variety of values of the weight per loop ddd in the ground state. For d=\sqrt{2}, a gapped non-abelian topological phase can occur with only four-spin interactions.
Condensation of quantum loops naturally leads to topological phases with Abelian excitations. Here, I propose that non-Abelian topological phases can arise from merging two (or several) identical Abelian quantum loop condensates. I define merging through a symmetrization operation, which makes the two loop condensates indistinguishable, inducing the possibility of a topological degeneracy in the space of quasiparticles. To illustrate the construction, the case of two identical toric-code quantum loop gases is considered. A spin-1 model for the two-dimensional square lattice is presented for which the resulting merged state is the exact unique ground state. This Hamiltonian involves four-body interactions between spins located at the same plaquette or vertex, which are quadratic in the spin-1 operators. Vertex and plaquette interaction terms are not mutually commuting. The model displays gapped excitations that result from merging anyons in both toric-code copies. These excitations exhibit non-Abelian braiding properties.
Local non-unitary deformations of topologically ordered wavefunctions can drive transitions into peculiar states that challenge modern perspectives on gapped quantum matter. The strongly deformed toric code offers a curious case, hosting mmm anyon condensation alongside perimeter-law scaling of Wilson loops charged under an exact 1-form symmetry---properties that typically do not coexist in gapped ground states. Nevertheless, we rigorously construct local gapped parent Hamiltonians for these strongly deformed toric code states. The Hamiltonians we construct are not strictly finite-range, but contain sums of Wilson loop operators whose coefficients decay exponentially in their diameter. If one adopts standard locality bounds used to define gapped phases---which allow for such exponentially decaying terms---our construction shows that these states realize a trivial gapped phase. Within this locality class, we demonstrate that perimeter-law scaling of Wilson loops does not imply a spontaneously broken 1-form symmetry, and from a dual perspective, that long-range ferromagnetic order and perimeter-law disorder parameter correlations can coexist in a 2D gapped ground state. We evade a recent no-go theorem [Sahay et al., arXiv:2503.01977] by relaxing its assumptions in a manner that we quantify as benign in the thermodynamic limit. More broadly, our results highlight that stronger notions of locality are necessary for prohibiting these counterintuitive properties within a gapped phase.
String-net condensation can give rise to non-Abelian anyons whereas loop condensation usually gives rise to Abelian anyons. It has been proposed that generalized quantum loop gases with non-orthogonal inner products can produce non-Abelian anyons. We detail an exact mapping between the string-net and the generalized loop models and explain how the non-orthogonal products arise. We also introduce a loop model of double-stranded nets where quantum loops with an orthogonal inner product and local interactions supports non-Abelian Fibonacci anyons. Finally we emphasize the origin of the sign problem in such systems and its consequences on the complexity of their ground state wave functions.
It is well known that an exponentially localized Hamiltonian must be gapless if its ground state has algebraic correlations. We show that even certain exponentially decaying correlations can imply gaplessness. This is exemplified by the deformed toric code ∝exp⁡(β∑ℓZℓ)∣TC⟩\propto \exp(β\sum_{\ell} Z_{\ell}) |\mathsf{TC}\rangle∝exp(β∑ℓ​Zℓ​)∣TC⟩, where ∣TC⟩|\mathsf{TC}\rangle∣TC⟩ is a fixed-point toric code wavefunction. Although it has a confined regime for β>βcβ> β_cβ>βc​, recent work has drawn attention to its perimeter law loop correlations. Here, we show that these unusual loop correlations -- namely, perimeter law coexisting with a 1-form symmetry whose disorder operator has long-range order -- imply that any local parent Hamiltonian must either be gapless or have a degeneracy scaling with system size. Moreover, we construct a variational low-energy state for arbitrary local frustration-free Hamiltonians, upper bounding the finite-size gap by O(1/L3)O(1/L^3)O(1/L3) on periodic boundary conditions. Strikingly, these variational states look like loop waves -- non-quasiparticle analogs of spin waves -- generated from the ground state by non-local loop operators. Our findings have implications for identifying the subset of Hilbert space to which gapped ground states belong, and the techniques have wide applicability. For instance, a corollary of our first result is that Glauber dynamics for the ordered phase of the two-dimensional classical Ising model on the torus must have a gapless Markov transition matrix, with our second result bounding its gap.
We study a quantum spin liquid called Kitaev’s toric code, which exhibits topological order [4-6]. This system is attractive since many of its properties can be analytically explored. As in the BCS and fractional quantum Hall cases, one first guesses the correct trial wave function for the ground state and then constructs quasiparticle excitations. In the toric code, some of these excitations exhibit Abelian anyon (semion) statistics. The topological entanglement entropy of this phase is finite, equal to ln 2. Moreover, the ground state is four-fold degenerate in a torus topology. (Note that the Laughlin state at filling factor 1/3 has degeneracy 3 and the superconducting state has degeneracy 4.) Some of these properties of the toric code, especially the appearance of a pair of non-local excitations, are similar to those of interacting disordered zigzag nanoribbons and the reader is encouraged to study this chapter carefully. The presentation of this chapter is somewhat heuristic. For a more refined treatment, see, for example Refs. [2, 3].