Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0804.4523 · Quantum Information and Computation

A non-distillability criterion for secret correlations

Lluís Masanes, Andreas Winter

Published Jan 1, 2010• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Within entanglement theory there are criteria which certify that some quantum states cannot be distilled into pure entanglement. An example is the positive partial transposition criterion. Here we present, for the first time, the analogous thing for secret correlations. We introduce a computable criterion which certifies that a probability distribution between two honest parties and an eavesdropper cannot be (asymptotically) distilled into a secret key. The existence of non-distillable correlations with positive secrecy cost, also known as bound information, is an open question. This criterion may be the key for finding bound information. However, if it turns out that this criterion does not detect bound information, then, a very interesting consequence follows: any distribution with positive secrecy cost can increase the secrecy content of another distribution. In other words, all correlations with positive secrecy cost constitute a useful resource.

DOI
10.26421/qic10.1-2-11

Related papers

Bipartite Bound Information Exists

Jef Pauwels, Nicolas Gisin, Renato Renner

There exist bipartite quantum states that cost entanglement to create, yet from which no singlet can be distilled. This extreme irreversibility is known as bound entanglement. A quarter-century ago, Gisin and Wolf asked whether classical information theory admits the same phenomenon. Are there correlations, shared by two parties and an eavesdropper, that cost secret bits to create, yet from which none can be distilled? This question is part of a broader program exploring the relation between quantum and classical information theory. We answer it in the affirmative, providing a simple example, a distribution of two bits and a trit. Bound entanglement thus has a classical counterpart, bound information. An even more direct correspondence was originally conjectured, namely that measuring purifications of bound-entangled states yields distributions with bound information. The very states that motivated the conjecture, however, yield no bound information when measured in the standard basis, whereas suitable measurements of purifications of separable states do. The analogy between bound entanglement and bound information thus lies in the accounting of resources, not in a correspondence between individual quantum states and the classical probability distributions induced by measuring them.

quant-pharXiv:2607.25838•Jul 29, 2026•1 citation

Multipartite Secret Correlations and Bound Information

Lluís Masanes, Antonio Acín

The problem of secret key extraction when n honest parties and an eavesdropper share correlated information is considered. A family of probability distributions is introduced and the full characterization of its distillation properties is presented. This formalism allows to design a rich variety of cryptographic scenarios. In particular, the existence of multipartite probability distributions containing nondistillable secret correlations, also known as bound information, can be proved

arXiv:cs/0501008•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Sep 29, 2006•8 citations

Information-theoretical Secret-key agreement and Bound information

Martin Kreißig

One big problem of the communication between two parties is the secrecy. That means how\nmuch information a third party can obtain by intercepting the messages transmitted from\none honest party to the other one. Therefore cryptography offers a wide range of protocols\nto ensure security with assumptions on the eavesdropper. So one was looking for an\ninformation-theoretical description of the scenario to get unconditional secure communication.\nIn this scenario we are considering two honest parties that want to communicate over\nan authenticated channel that the eavesdropper is wiretapping. This scenario introduced the definition of the intrinsic information and the secret-key rate which are a measure of the secrecy in this setting. Later because of strong analogies to quantum mechanics it turned out that this description was lacking a phenomena called bound information which is the disability of a probability distribution to create a secret-key even though it has predicted secrecy.\nNearly ten years of research have shown the existence of bound information for the multipartite case where several parties are communicating but not yet for the bipartite case.\nHence the approach of non-distillability seems a very promising one to find this conjecture.\nMotivated by this the approach we implemented this tool and simulated some distributions that have conjectured bound information. Thereby we improved the tool to reduce its calculationtime and to get closer to the aim.

•Feb 25, 2009•1 citation

Can bipartite classical information resources be activated?

Giuseppe Prettico, Antonio Acín

Non-additivity is one of the distinctive traits of Quantum Information Theory: the combined use of quantum objects may be more advantageous than the sum of their individual uses. Non-additivity effects have been proven, for example, for quantum channel capacities, entanglement distillation or state estimation. In this work, we consider whether non-additivity effects can be found in Classical Information Theory. We work in the secret-key agreement scenario in which two honest parties, having access to correlated classical data that are also correlated to an eavesdropper, aim at distilling a secret key. Exploiting the analogies between the entanglement and the secret-key agreement scenario, we provide some evidence that the secret-key rate may be a non-additive quantity. In particular, we show that correlations with conjectured bound information become secret-key distillable when combined. Our results constitute a new instance of the subtle relation between the entanglement and secret-key agreement scenario.

arXiv:1203.1445•Quantum Information and Computation•Mar 1, 2013•1 citation

Quantum cryptographic resource distillation and entanglement

Minjin Choi, Soojoon Lee

We look into multipartite quantum states on which quantum cryptographic protocols including quantum key distribution and quantum secret sharing can be perfectly performed, and define the quantum cryptographic resource distillable rate as the asymptotic rate at which such multipartite state can be distilled from a given multipartite state. Investigating several relations between entanglement and the rate, we show that there exists a multipartite bound entangled state whose quantum cryptographic resource distillable rate is strictly positive, that is, there exists a multipartite entangled state which is not distillable, but can be useful for quantum cryptography such as quantum key distribution and quantum secret sharing.

arXiv:2110.13707•Scientific Reports•Oct 26, 2021•4 citations

Distillation of secret key and entanglement from quantum states

Igor Devetak, Andreas Winter

We study and solve the problem of distilling a secret key from quantum states representing correlation between two parties (Alice and Bob) and an eavesdropper (Eve) via one–way public discussion: we prove a coding theorem to achieve the ‘wire–tapper’ bound, the difference of the mutual information Alice–Bob and that of Alice–Eve, for so–called classical–quantum–quantum–correlations, via one–way public communication. This result yields information–theoretic formulae for the distillable secret key, giving ‘ultimate’ key rate bounds if Eve is assumed to possess a purification of Alice and Bob's joint state. Specializing our protocol somewhat and making it coherent leads us to a protocol of entanglement distillation via one–way LOCC (local operations and classical communication) which is asymptotically optimal: in fact we prove the so–called ‘hashing inequality’, which says that the coherent information (i.e. the negative conditional von Neumann entropy) is an achievable Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen rate. This result is known to imply a whole set of distillation and capacity formulae, which we briefly review.

arXiv:quant-ph/0306078•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Oct 19, 2004•1,088 citations
Within entanglement theory there are criteria which certify that some quantum states cannot be distilled into pure entanglement. An example is the positive partial transposition criterion. Here we present, for the first time, the analogous thing for secret correlations. We introduce a computable criterion which certifies that a probability distribution between two honest parties and an eavesdropper cannot be (asymptotically) distilled into a secret key. The existence of non-distillable correlations with positive secrecy cost, also known as bound information, is an open question. This criterion may be the key for finding bound information. However, if it turns out that this criterion does not detect bound information, then, a very interesting consequence follows: any distribution with positive secrecy cost can increase the secrecy content of another distribution. In other words, all correlations with positive secrecy cost constitute a useful resource.
There exist bipartite quantum states that cost entanglement to create, yet from which no singlet can be distilled. This extreme irreversibility is known as bound entanglement. A quarter-century ago, Gisin and Wolf asked whether classical information theory admits the same phenomenon. Are there correlations, shared by two parties and an eavesdropper, that cost secret bits to create, yet from which none can be distilled? This question is part of a broader program exploring the relation between quantum and classical information theory. We answer it in the affirmative, providing a simple example, a distribution of two bits and a trit. Bound entanglement thus has a classical counterpart, bound information. An even more direct correspondence was originally conjectured, namely that measuring purifications of bound-entangled states yields distributions with bound information. The very states that motivated the conjecture, however, yield no bound information when measured in the standard basis, whereas suitable measurements of purifications of separable states do. The analogy between bound entanglement and bound information thus lies in the accounting of resources, not in a correspondence between individual quantum states and the classical probability distributions induced by measuring them.
One big problem of the communication between two parties is the secrecy. That means how\nmuch information a third party can obtain by intercepting the messages transmitted from\none honest party to the other one. Therefore cryptography offers a wide range of protocols\nto ensure security with assumptions on the eavesdropper. So one was looking for an\ninformation-theoretical description of the scenario to get unconditional secure communication.\nIn this scenario we are considering two honest parties that want to communicate over\nan authenticated channel that the eavesdropper is wiretapping. This scenario introduced the definition of the intrinsic information and the secret-key rate which are a measure of the secrecy in this setting. Later because of strong analogies to quantum mechanics it turned out that this description was lacking a phenomena called bound information which is the disability of a probability distribution to create a secret-key even though it has predicted secrecy.\nNearly ten years of research have shown the existence of bound information for the multipartite case where several parties are communicating but not yet for the bipartite case.\nHence the approach of non-distillability seems a very promising one to find this conjecture.\nMotivated by this the approach we implemented this tool and simulated some distributions that have conjectured bound information. Thereby we improved the tool to reduce its calculationtime and to get closer to the aim.
Non-additivity is one of the distinctive traits of Quantum Information Theory: the combined use of quantum objects may be more advantageous than the sum of their individual uses. Non-additivity effects have been proven, for example, for quantum channel capacities, entanglement distillation or state estimation. In this work, we consider whether non-additivity effects can be found in Classical Information Theory. We work in the secret-key agreement scenario in which two honest parties, having access to correlated classical data that are also correlated to an eavesdropper, aim at distilling a secret key. Exploiting the analogies between the entanglement and the secret-key agreement scenario, we provide some evidence that the secret-key rate may be a non-additive quantity. In particular, we show that correlations with conjectured bound information become secret-key distillable when combined. Our results constitute a new instance of the subtle relation between the entanglement and secret-key agreement scenario.
We look into multipartite quantum states on which quantum cryptographic protocols including quantum key distribution and quantum secret sharing can be perfectly performed, and define the quantum cryptographic resource distillable rate as the asymptotic rate at which such multipartite state can be distilled from a given multipartite state. Investigating several relations between entanglement and the rate, we show that there exists a multipartite bound entangled state whose quantum cryptographic resource distillable rate is strictly positive, that is, there exists a multipartite entangled state which is not distillable, but can be useful for quantum cryptography such as quantum key distribution and quantum secret sharing.
We study and solve the problem of distilling a secret key from quantum states representing correlation between two parties (Alice and Bob) and an eavesdropper (Eve) via one–way public discussion: we prove a coding theorem to achieve the ‘wire–tapper’ bound, the difference of the mutual information Alice–Bob and that of Alice–Eve, for so–called classical–quantum–quantum–correlations, via one–way public communication. This result yields information–theoretic formulae for the distillable secret key, giving ‘ultimate’ key rate bounds if Eve is assumed to possess a purification of Alice and Bob's joint state. Specializing our protocol somewhat and making it coherent leads us to a protocol of entanglement distillation via one–way LOCC (local operations and classical communication) which is asymptotically optimal: in fact we prove the so–called ‘hashing inequality’, which says that the coherent information (i.e. the negative conditional von Neumann entropy) is an achievable Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen rate. This result is known to imply a whole set of distillation and capacity formulae, which we briefly review.