Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0804.3487

Comment on the Quantum Brachistochrone Problem

Carl M. Bender, Dorje C. Brody, Hugh F Jones, Bernhard K. Meister

Published Apr 22, 2008• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this brief comment we attempt to clarify the apparent discrepancy between the papers [1] and [2] on the quantum brachistochrone, namely whether it is possible to use a judicious mixture of Hermitian and non-Hermitian quantum mechanics to evade the standard lower limit on the time taken for evolution by a Hermitian Hamiltonian with given energy dispersion between two given states.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.0804.3487

Related papers

Comments on "Observation of Fast Evolution in Parity-Time-Symmetric System"

Fabio Masillo

In the paper "Observation of Fast Evolution in Parity-Time-Symmetric System" the authors propose a physical apparatus for the realization of a faster than Hermitian evolution. This last appears in contrast with the conclusions obtained in our paper "Some Remarks on Quantum Brachistochrone". We will clarify this apparent contradiction and some problematic aspects of the treatment in [1].

arXiv:1106.1550•Jun 8, 2011•1 citation

Faster than Hermitian Quantum Mechanics

Carl M. Bender, Dorje C. Brody, Hugh F Jones +1 more

Given an initial quantum state $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{I}⟩$ and a final quantum state $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{F}⟩$, there exist Hamiltonians $H$ under which $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{I}⟩$ evolves into $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{F}⟩$. Consider the following quantum brachistochrone problem: subject to the constraint that the difference between the largest and smallest eigenvalues of $H$ is held fixed, which $H$ achieves this transformation in the least time $\ensuremath{\tau}$? For Hermitian Hamiltonians $\ensuremath{\tau}$ has a nonzero lower bound. However, among non-Hermitian $\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}$-symmetric Hamiltonians satisfying the same energy constraint, $\ensuremath{\tau}$ can be made arbitrarily small without violating the time-energy uncertainty principle. This is because for such Hamiltonians the path from $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{I}⟩$ to $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{F}⟩$ can be made short. The mechanism described here is similar to that in general relativity in which the distance between two space-time points can be made small if they are connected by a wormhole. This result may have applications in quantum computing.

arXiv:quant-ph/0609032•Physical Review Letters•Jan 24, 2007•419 citations

Non-Hermitian Quantum Systems and Time-Optimal Quantum Evolution

Alexander I. Nesterov

Recently, Bender et al. have considered the quantum brachistochrone problem for the non-Hermitian PT -symmetric quantum system and have shown that the optimal time evolution required to transform a given initial state |ψ i into a specific final state |ψ f can be made arbitrarily small.Additionally, it has been shown that finding the shortest possible time requires only the solution of the two-dimensional problem for the quantum system governed by the effective Hamiltonian acting in the subspace spanned by |ψ i and |ψ f .In this paper, we study a similar problem for the generic non-Hermitian Hamiltonian, focusing our attention on the geometric aspects of the problem.

arXiv:0707.2736•Symmetry Integrability and Geometry Methods and Applications•Jul 7, 2009•11 citations

The quantum brachistochrone problem for non-Hermitian Hamiltonians

Paulo E G Assis, Andreas Fring

Recently Bender, Brody, Jones and Meister found that in the quantum brachistochrone problem the passage time needed for the evolution of certain initial states into specified final states can be made arbitrarily small, when the time-evolution operator is taken to be non-Hermitian but -symmetric. Here we demonstrate that such phenomena can also be obtained for non-Hermitian Hamiltonians for which -symmetry is completely broken, i.e. dissipative systems. We observe that the effect of a tunable passage time can be achieved by projecting between orthogonal eigenstates by means of a time-evolution operator associated with a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian. It is not essential that this Hamiltonian is -symmetric.

arXiv:quant-ph/0703254•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jun 3, 2008•48 citations

On "non-Hermitian Quantum Mechanics"

M. J. Everitt, Shaaban Khalil, Alexandre M. Zagoskin

A series of recent papers ``Faster than Hermitian Quantum Mechanics'' and related articles made a point of the possibility of a non-Hermitian, but PT-symmetric, operator to play the role of a Hamiltonian. In particular, they show that with an appropriate choice of an inner product, the evolution generated by such an operator will conserve the norm and scalar product. Here we observe that if one chooses such an inner product then the Hamiltonian in question is actually Hermitian, and the whole exercise is to a certain degree redundant.

arXiv:0804.2051•Apr 13, 2008•0 citations

Reply to Comment on ``Time-dependent quasi-Hermitian Hamiltonians and the unitary quantum evolution''

Miloslav Znojil

In his fresh "Comment" (arXiv:0711.0137v1), A. Mostafazadeh reacts on my very recent letter (arXiv:0710.5653v1) where I tried to clarify certain misunderstandings which occurred in A. M., Phys. Lett. B \textbf{650}, 208 (2007) [arXiv:0706.1872v2, "Paper"]. As long as the "Comment" offers a new support of the original assertions made in the "Paper", I feel obliged to re-clarify the matter by extending my argumentation. I insist that it is possible to escape the main conclusion of the "Paper", indeed. In particular, I point out a gap in the new calculations in "Comment", add a few remarks on the notation and reconfirm that the unitarity of the time-evolution DOES NOT require the time-independence of the metric operator.

arXiv:0711.0514•Nov 5, 2007•12 citations
In this brief comment we attempt to clarify the apparent discrepancy between the papers [1] and [2] on the quantum brachistochrone, namely whether it is possible to use a judicious mixture of Hermitian and non-Hermitian quantum mechanics to evade the standard lower limit on the time taken for evolution by a Hermitian Hamiltonian with given energy dispersion between two given states.
Given an initial quantum state $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{I}⟩$ and a final quantum state $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{F}⟩$, there exist Hamiltonians HHH under which $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{I}⟩$ evolves into $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{F}⟩$. Consider the following quantum brachistochrone problem: subject to the constraint that the difference between the largest and smallest eigenvalues of HHH is held fixed, which HHH achieves this transformation in the least time $\ensuremath{\tau}$? For Hermitian Hamiltonians $\ensuremath{\tau}$ has a nonzero lower bound. However, among non-Hermitian PT\mathcal{P}\mathcal{T}PT-symmetric Hamiltonians satisfying the same energy constraint, $\ensuremath{\tau}$ can be made arbitrarily small without violating the time-energy uncertainty principle. This is because for such Hamiltonians the path from $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{I}⟩$ to $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{F}⟩$ can be made short. The mechanism described here is similar to that in general relativity in which the distance between two space-time points can be made small if they are connected by a wormhole. This result may have applications in quantum computing.
Recently, Bender et al. have considered the quantum brachistochrone problem for the non-Hermitian PT -symmetric quantum system and have shown that the optimal time evolution required to transform a given initial state |ψ i into a specific final state |ψ f can be made arbitrarily small.Additionally, it has been shown that finding the shortest possible time requires only the solution of the two-dimensional problem for the quantum system governed by the effective Hamiltonian acting in the subspace spanned by |ψ i and |ψ f .In this paper, we study a similar problem for the generic non-Hermitian Hamiltonian, focusing our attention on the geometric aspects of the problem.
Recently Bender, Brody, Jones and Meister found that in the quantum brachistochrone problem the passage time needed for the evolution of certain initial states into specified final states can be made arbitrarily small, when the time-evolution operator is taken to be non-Hermitian but -symmetric. Here we demonstrate that such phenomena can also be obtained for non-Hermitian Hamiltonians for which -symmetry is completely broken, i.e. dissipative systems. We observe that the effect of a tunable passage time can be achieved by projecting between orthogonal eigenstates by means of a time-evolution operator associated with a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian. It is not essential that this Hamiltonian is -symmetric.
A series of recent papers ``Faster than Hermitian Quantum Mechanics'' and related articles made a point of the possibility of a non-Hermitian, but PT-symmetric, operator to play the role of a Hamiltonian. In particular, they show that with an appropriate choice of an inner product, the evolution generated by such an operator will conserve the norm and scalar product. Here we observe that if one chooses such an inner product then the Hamiltonian in question is actually Hermitian, and the whole exercise is to a certain degree redundant.
In his fresh "Comment" (arXiv:0711.0137v1), A. Mostafazadeh reacts on my very recent letter (arXiv:0710.5653v1) where I tried to clarify certain misunderstandings which occurred in A. M., Phys. Lett. B \textbf{650}, 208 (2007) [arXiv:0706.1872v2, "Paper"]. As long as the "Comment" offers a new support of the original assertions made in the "Paper", I feel obliged to re-clarify the matter by extending my argumentation. I insist that it is possible to escape the main conclusion of the "Paper", indeed. In particular, I point out a gap in the new calculations in "Comment", add a few remarks on the notation and reconfirm that the unitarity of the time-evolution DOES NOT require the time-independence of the metric operator.