Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0712.0686 · Journal of the Korean Physical Society

Violation of Rotational Invariance of Local Realistic Models with Two Settings

Koji Nagata, Jaewook Ahn

Published Oct 15, 2008• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We have considered a two-particle Bell experiment to visualize the conflict between rotational invariance of physical laws and a specific local realistic theory. The experiment is reproducible by using a local realistic theory obtained in a two-setting Bell experiment. The generalized Bell inequality {[J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. {\bf 40}, 13101 (2007)]}, which is derived under the assumption that there exists a rotationally invariant local realistic theory, turns out to disprove such a local realistic model existing with a two-setting experiment. This implies that such a model is not rotationally invariant and should, therefore, be ruled out in some situations.

DOI
10.3938/jkps.53.2216

Related papers

THE CONFLICT BETWEEN BELL–ŻUKOWSKI INEQUALITY AND BELL–MERMIN INEQUALITY

Koji Nagata, Jaewook Ahn

We consider a two-particle/two-setting Bell experiment to visualize the conflict between Bell–Żukowski inequality and Bell–Mermin inequality. The experiment is reproducible by local realistic theories which are not rotationally invariant. We find that the average value of Bell–Żukowski operator is evaluated by the two-particle/two-setting Bell experiment in question. Bell–Żukowski inequality reveals that the constructed local realistic theories for the experiment are not rotationally invariant. The two-particle Bell experiment in question reveals the conflict between Bell–Żukowski inequality and Bell–Mermin inequality. Our analysis finds the threshold visibility for the two-particle interference to reveal the conflict noted above. The threshold visibility agrees with the value to obtain a violation of Bell–Żukowski inequality.

arXiv:quant-ph/0302090•Modern Physics Letters A•Nov 19, 2008•6 citations

RotationalInvariance as an Additional Constraint on Local Realism

Koji Nagata, Wiesław Laskowski, Marcin Wieśniak +1 more

Rotational invariance of physical laws is a generally accepted principle. We show that it leads to an additional external constraint on local realistic models of physical phenomena involving measurements of multiparticle spin 1/2 correlations. This new constraint rules out such models even in some situations in which standard Bell inequalities allow for explicit construction of such models. The whole analysis is performed without any additional assumptions on the form of local realistic models.

arXiv:quant-ph/0407232•Physical Review Letters•Dec 3, 2004•32 citations

An Additional Constraint on Local Realism with Mixture of Ten- Particle Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger State Implied by Rotational Invariance

Koji Nagata, Tadao Nakamura

Rotational invariance of physical laws is an accepted principle in Newton’s theory. We show that it leads to an additional constraint on local realistic theories with mixture of ten-particle Greenberger- Horne-Zeilinger state. This new constraint rules out such theories even in some situations in which standard Bell inequalities allow for explicit construction of such theories.

•Mar 1, 2016•0 citations

New Method to Reveal the Conflict Between Local Realism and Quantum Mechanics

Koji Nagata, Jaewook Ahn

We formulate the expectation value of the Bell-Zukowski operator acting on qubit states of a two-particle Bell experiment. By using the equivalence between a set of N copies of a two-qubit experiment and a standard two-setting Bell experiment in an entangled 2N-particle state, we obtain an inequality, which we may call the Bell-Zukowski inequality. It determines whether the measured correlation functions of two-particle states can be modeled locally and realistically. In this Bell experiment of two particles, the conflict between local realism and quantum mechanics is discussed in conjunction with the violation of the Bell-Zukowski inequality. The main point of the result is that the Bell-Zukowski operator can be represented by the Bell-Mermin operator. The threshold visibility of two-particle interference analyzed in this scheme shows good agreement with the value to cause a violation of the Bell-Zukowski inequality.

arXiv:0811.3275•Journal of the Korean Physical Society•Dec 15, 2008•0 citations

Collapse of Bell’s Theorem

Guangye Chen

Bell’s theorem founded on Bell’s inequalities asserts that no local realistic theories can reproduce all quantum mechanical predictions for spin correlation of particle pairs. It is pointed out that the assumption of setting-independent probability makes Bell’s inequalities not impose constraint on all local realistic models and thus constitutes a theoretical loophole of Bell’s theorem. A counterexample is presented by showing that a local realistic model with appropriate probability density reproduces all quantum mechanical predictions. It becomes clear that experiments violate Bell’s inequalities because the real correlation functions are not constrained by these inequalities. It is also exposed that, rigorous logical reasoning of counter factual deduction does not permit to exclude any premises of Bell’s inequalities by a certain amount of experimental violations of these inequalities.

Journal of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 2019•4 citations

Experimental Test of Nonlocal Realistic Theories Without the Rotational Symmetry Assumption

Tomasz Paterek, Alessandro Fedrizzi, Simon Gröblacher +4 more

We analyze the class of nonlocal realistic theories that was originally considered by Leggett [Found. Phys. 33, 1469 (2003)10.1023/A:1026096313729] and tested by us in a recent experiment [Nature (London) 446, 871 (2007)10.1038/nature05677]. We derive an incompatibility theorem that works for finite numbers of polarizer settings and that does not require the previously assumed rotational symmetry of the two-particle correlation functions. The experimentally measured case involves seven different measurement settings. Using polarization-entangled photon pairs, we exclude this broader class of nonlocal realistic models by experimentally violating a new Leggett-type inequality by 80 standard deviations.

arXiv:0708.0813•Physical Review Letters•Nov 21, 2007•103 citations
We have considered a two-particle Bell experiment to visualize the conflict between rotational invariance of physical laws and a specific local realistic theory. The experiment is reproducible by using a local realistic theory obtained in a two-setting Bell experiment. The generalized Bell inequality {[J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. {\bf 40}, 13101 (2007)]}, which is derived under the assumption that there exists a rotationally invariant local realistic theory, turns out to disprove such a local realistic model existing with a two-setting experiment. This implies that such a model is not rotationally invariant and should, therefore, be ruled out in some situations.
We consider a two-particle/two-setting Bell experiment to visualize the conflict between Bell–Żukowski inequality and Bell–Mermin inequality. The experiment is reproducible by local realistic theories which are not rotationally invariant. We find that the average value of Bell–Żukowski operator is evaluated by the two-particle/two-setting Bell experiment in question. Bell–Żukowski inequality reveals that the constructed local realistic theories for the experiment are not rotationally invariant. The two-particle Bell experiment in question reveals the conflict between Bell–Żukowski inequality and Bell–Mermin inequality. Our analysis finds the threshold visibility for the two-particle interference to reveal the conflict noted above. The threshold visibility agrees with the value to obtain a violation of Bell–Żukowski inequality.
We formulate the expectation value of the Bell-Zukowski operator acting on qubit states of a two-particle Bell experiment. By using the equivalence between a set of N copies of a two-qubit experiment and a standard two-setting Bell experiment in an entangled 2N-particle state, we obtain an inequality, which we may call the Bell-Zukowski inequality. It determines whether the measured correlation functions of two-particle states can be modeled locally and realistically. In this Bell experiment of two particles, the conflict between local realism and quantum mechanics is discussed in conjunction with the violation of the Bell-Zukowski inequality. The main point of the result is that the Bell-Zukowski operator can be represented by the Bell-Mermin operator. The threshold visibility of two-particle interference analyzed in this scheme shows good agreement with the value to cause a violation of the Bell-Zukowski inequality.
Bell’s theorem founded on Bell’s inequalities asserts that no local realistic theories can reproduce all quantum mechanical predictions for spin correlation of particle pairs. It is pointed out that the assumption of setting-independent probability makes Bell’s inequalities not impose constraint on all local realistic models and thus constitutes a theoretical loophole of Bell’s theorem. A counterexample is presented by showing that a local realistic model with appropriate probability density reproduces all quantum mechanical predictions. It becomes clear that experiments violate Bell’s inequalities because the real correlation functions are not constrained by these inequalities. It is also exposed that, rigorous logical reasoning of counter factual deduction does not permit to exclude any premises of Bell’s inequalities by a certain amount of experimental violations of these inequalities.
We analyze the class of nonlocal realistic theories that was originally considered by Leggett [Found. Phys. 33, 1469 (2003)10.1023/A:1026096313729] and tested by us in a recent experiment [Nature (London) 446, 871 (2007)10.1038/nature05677]. We derive an incompatibility theorem that works for finite numbers of polarizer settings and that does not require the previously assumed rotational symmetry of the two-particle correlation functions. The experimentally measured case involves seven different measurement settings. Using polarization-entangled photon pairs, we exclude this broader class of nonlocal realistic models by experimentally violating a new Leggett-type inequality by 80 standard deviations.