Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0710.2765 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Note on the existence theorem in ‘emergent quantum mechanics and emergent symmetries’

Hans-Thomas Elze

Published Jul 15, 2008• 20 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Recently 't Hooft demonstrated that ‘ For any quantum system there exists at least one deterministic model that reproduces all its dynamics after prequantization’ . An extension is presented here which covers quantum systems that are characterized by a complete set of mutually commuting Hermitian operators ( beables ). We introduce the symmetry of beables: any complete set of beables is as good as any other one which is obtained through a real general linear group transformation. The quantum numbers of a specific set are related to symmetry breaking initial and boundary conditions in a deterministic model. The Hamiltonian, in particular, can be taken as the emergent beable which provides the best resolution of the evolution of the model universe.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/41/30/304020

Related papers

Symmetry aspects in emergent quantum mechanics

Hans-Thomas Elze

We discuss an explicit realization of the dissipative dynamics anticipated in the proof of 't Hooft's existence theorem, which states that ' For any quantum system there exists at least one deterministic model that reproduces all its dynamics after prequantization' . – There is an energy-parity symmetry hidden in the Liouville equation, which mimics the Kaplan-Sundrum protective symmetry for the cosmological constant. This symmetry may be broken by the coarse-graining inherent in physics at scales much larger than the Planck length. We correspondingly modify classical ensemble theory by incorporating dissipative fluctuations (information loss) – which are caused by discrete spacetime continually 'measuring' matter. In this way, aspects of quantum mechanics, such as the von Neumann equation, including a Lindblad term, arise dynamically and expectations of observables agree with the Born rule. However, the resulting quantum coherence is accompanied by an intrinsic decoherence and continuous localization mechanism. Our proposal leads towards a theory that is linear and local at the quantum mechanical level, but the relation to the underlying classical degrees of freedom is nonlocal.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2009•12 citations

THE ATTRACTOR AND THE QUANTUM STATES

Hans-Thomas Elze

The dissipative dynamics anticipated in the proof of 't Hooft's existence theorem — "For any quantum system there exists at least one deterministic model that reproduces all its dynamics after prequantization" — is constructed here explicitly. We propose a generalization of Liouville's classical phase space equation, incorporating dissipation and diffusion, and demonstrate that it describes the emergence of quantum states and their dynamics in the Schrödinger picture. Asymptotically, there is a stable ground state and two decoupled sets of degrees of freedom, which transform into each other under the energy-parity symmetry of Kaplan and Sundrum. They recover the familiar Hilbert space and its dual. Expectations of observables are shown to agree with the Born rule, which is not imposed a priori. This attractor mechanism is applicable in the presence of interactions, to few-body or field theories in particular.

arXiv:0806.3408•International Journal of Quantum Information•Jan 1, 2009•38 citations

Beables in Algebraic Quantum Mechanics

Rob Clifton

John Bell once argued that one ought to select, out of the 'observables' of quantum theory, some subset of 'beables' that can be consistently ascribed determinate values. Moreover, this subset should be selected so as to guarantee (among other things) that we can dispense with the orthodox interpretation's loose talk about 'measurement values': "...the probability of a beable being a particular value would be calculated just as was formerly calculated the probability of observing that value". Working in the framework of C*-algebras (in particular, Segal algebras), I propose an algebraic characterization of those subsets of bounded observables of a quantum system that can have beable status with respect to any (fixed) state of the system. It turns out that observables with beable status in a state need not all commute (a possibility Bell himself does not consider), but they must at least form a certain kind of 'quasicommutative' subalgebra determined by the state. A virtue of the analysis is that it applies to beables with continuous spectra, usually neglected in discussions of the no-hidden-variables theorems. In the (very) special case where the algebra of observables for a system is representable on a finite-dimensional Hilbert space, I give a complete characterization of the maximal beable subalgebras determined by any state of the system; the infinite-dimensional case remains open. These results are discussed in relation to previous results of a similar nature, to 'no-collapse' interpretations of quantum mechanics, and to algebraic relativistic quantum field theory.

arXiv:quant-ph/9711009•Nov 9, 1997•9 citations

Emergent Quantum Mechanics and Emergent Symmetries

Gerard ’t Hooft, Arttu K. Rajantie, Carlo Contaldi +2 more

Quantum mechanics is ‘emergent’ if a statistical treatment of large scale phenomena in a locally deterministic theory requires the use of quantum operators. These quantum operators may allow for symmetry transformations that are not present in the underlying deterministic system. Such theories allow for a natural explanation of the existence of gauge equivalence classes (gauge orbits), including the equivalence classes generated by general coordinate transformations. Thus, local gauge symmetries and general coordinate invariance could be emergent symmetries, and this might lead to new alleys towards understanding the flatness problem of the Universe.

arXiv:0707.4568•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2007•88 citations

Symmetries of quantum evolutions

Giulio Chiribella, Erik Aurell, Karol Życzkowski

A cornerstone of quantum mechanics is the characterization of symmetries provided by Wigner's theorem. Wigner's theorem establishes that every symmetry of the quantum state space must be either a unitary transformation or an antiunitary transformation. Here we extend Wigner's theorem from quantum states to quantum evolutions, including both the deterministic evolution associated with the dynamics of closed systems and the stochastic evolutions associated with the outcomes of quantum measurements. We prove that every symmetry of the space of quantum evolutions can be decomposed into two state space symmetries that are either both unitary or both antiunitary. Building on this result, we show that it is impossible to extend the time-reversal symmetry of unitary quantum dynamics to a symmetry of the full set of quantum evolutions. Our no-go theorem implies that any time-symmetric formulation of quantum theory must either restrict the set of the allowed evolutions or modify the operational interpretation of quantum states and processes. Here we propose a time-symmetric formulation of quantum theory where the allowed quantum evolutions are restricted to a suitable set, which includes both unitary evolution and projective measurements but excludes the deterministic preparation of pure states. The standard operational formulation of quantum theory can be retrieved from this time-symmetric version by introducing an operation of conditioning on the outcomes of past experiments.

arXiv:2101.04962•Physical Review Research•Jul 6, 2021•29 citations

Symmetries and Invariants for Non-Hermitian Hamiltonians

Miguel Angel Otero Simón, Álvaro Buendía, Juan Gonzalo Muga

We discuss Hamiltonian symmetries and invariants for quantum systems driven by non-Hermitian Hamiltonians. For time-independent Hermitian Hamiltonians, a unitary or antiunitary transformation AHA† that leaves the Hamiltonian H unchanged represents a symmetry of the Hamiltonian, which implies the commutativity [H,A]=0 and, if A is linear and time-independent, a conservation law, namely the invariance of expectation values of A. For non-Hermitian Hamiltonians, H† comes into play as a distinct operator that complements H in generalized unitarity relations. The above description of symmetries has to be extended to include also A-pseudohermiticity relations of the form AH=H†A. A superoperator formulation of Hamiltonian symmetries is provided and exemplified for Hamiltonians of a particle moving in one-dimension considering the set of A operators that form Klein’s 4-group: parity, time-reversal, parity&time-reversal, and unity. The link between symmetry and conservation laws is discussed and shown to be richer and subtler for non-Hermitian than for Hermitian Hamiltonians.

arXiv:1805.04968•Mathematics•Jun 27, 2018•20 citations
Recently 't Hooft demonstrated that ‘ For any quantum system there exists at least one deterministic model that reproduces all its dynamics after prequantization’ . An extension is presented here which covers quantum systems that are characterized by a complete set of mutually commuting Hermitian operators ( beables ). We introduce the symmetry of beables: any complete set of beables is as good as any other one which is obtained through a real general linear group transformation. The quantum numbers of a specific set are related to symmetry breaking initial and boundary conditions in a deterministic model. The Hamiltonian, in particular, can be taken as the emergent beable which provides the best resolution of the evolution of the model universe.
We discuss an explicit realization of the dissipative dynamics anticipated in the proof of 't Hooft's existence theorem, which states that ' For any quantum system there exists at least one deterministic model that reproduces all its dynamics after prequantization' . – There is an energy-parity symmetry hidden in the Liouville equation, which mimics the Kaplan-Sundrum protective symmetry for the cosmological constant. This symmetry may be broken by the coarse-graining inherent in physics at scales much larger than the Planck length. We correspondingly modify classical ensemble theory by incorporating dissipative fluctuations (information loss) – which are caused by discrete spacetime continually 'measuring' matter. In this way, aspects of quantum mechanics, such as the von Neumann equation, including a Lindblad term, arise dynamically and expectations of observables agree with the Born rule. However, the resulting quantum coherence is accompanied by an intrinsic decoherence and continuous localization mechanism. Our proposal leads towards a theory that is linear and local at the quantum mechanical level, but the relation to the underlying classical degrees of freedom is nonlocal.
The dissipative dynamics anticipated in the proof of 't Hooft's existence theorem — "For any quantum system there exists at least one deterministic model that reproduces all its dynamics after prequantization" — is constructed here explicitly. We propose a generalization of Liouville's classical phase space equation, incorporating dissipation and diffusion, and demonstrate that it describes the emergence of quantum states and their dynamics in the Schrödinger picture. Asymptotically, there is a stable ground state and two decoupled sets of degrees of freedom, which transform into each other under the energy-parity symmetry of Kaplan and Sundrum. They recover the familiar Hilbert space and its dual. Expectations of observables are shown to agree with the Born rule, which is not imposed a priori. This attractor mechanism is applicable in the presence of interactions, to few-body or field theories in particular.
John Bell once argued that one ought to select, out of the 'observables' of quantum theory, some subset of 'beables' that can be consistently ascribed determinate values. Moreover, this subset should be selected so as to guarantee (among other things) that we can dispense with the orthodox interpretation's loose talk about 'measurement values': "...the probability of a beable being a particular value would be calculated just as was formerly calculated the probability of observing that value". Working in the framework of C*-algebras (in particular, Segal algebras), I propose an algebraic characterization of those subsets of bounded observables of a quantum system that can have beable status with respect to any (fixed) state of the system. It turns out that observables with beable status in a state need not all commute (a possibility Bell himself does not consider), but they must at least form a certain kind of 'quasicommutative' subalgebra determined by the state. A virtue of the analysis is that it applies to beables with continuous spectra, usually neglected in discussions of the no-hidden-variables theorems. In the (very) special case where the algebra of observables for a system is representable on a finite-dimensional Hilbert space, I give a complete characterization of the maximal beable subalgebras determined by any state of the system; the infinite-dimensional case remains open. These results are discussed in relation to previous results of a similar nature, to 'no-collapse' interpretations of quantum mechanics, and to algebraic relativistic quantum field theory.
Quantum mechanics is ‘emergent’ if a statistical treatment of large scale phenomena in a locally deterministic theory requires the use of quantum operators. These quantum operators may allow for symmetry transformations that are not present in the underlying deterministic system. Such theories allow for a natural explanation of the existence of gauge equivalence classes (gauge orbits), including the equivalence classes generated by general coordinate transformations. Thus, local gauge symmetries and general coordinate invariance could be emergent symmetries, and this might lead to new alleys towards understanding the flatness problem of the Universe.
A cornerstone of quantum mechanics is the characterization of symmetries provided by Wigner's theorem. Wigner's theorem establishes that every symmetry of the quantum state space must be either a unitary transformation or an antiunitary transformation. Here we extend Wigner's theorem from quantum states to quantum evolutions, including both the deterministic evolution associated with the dynamics of closed systems and the stochastic evolutions associated with the outcomes of quantum measurements. We prove that every symmetry of the space of quantum evolutions can be decomposed into two state space symmetries that are either both unitary or both antiunitary. Building on this result, we show that it is impossible to extend the time-reversal symmetry of unitary quantum dynamics to a symmetry of the full set of quantum evolutions. Our no-go theorem implies that any time-symmetric formulation of quantum theory must either restrict the set of the allowed evolutions or modify the operational interpretation of quantum states and processes. Here we propose a time-symmetric formulation of quantum theory where the allowed quantum evolutions are restricted to a suitable set, which includes both unitary evolution and projective measurements but excludes the deterministic preparation of pure states. The standard operational formulation of quantum theory can be retrieved from this time-symmetric version by introducing an operation of conditioning on the outcomes of past experiments.
We discuss Hamiltonian symmetries and invariants for quantum systems driven by non-Hermitian Hamiltonians. For time-independent Hermitian Hamiltonians, a unitary or antiunitary transformation AHA† that leaves the Hamiltonian H unchanged represents a symmetry of the Hamiltonian, which implies the commutativity [H,A]=0 and, if A is linear and time-independent, a conservation law, namely the invariance of expectation values of A. For non-Hermitian Hamiltonians, H† comes into play as a distinct operator that complements H in generalized unitarity relations. The above description of symmetries has to be extended to include also A-pseudohermiticity relations of the form AH=H†A. A superoperator formulation of Hamiltonian symmetries is provided and exemplified for Hamiltonians of a particle moving in one-dimension considering the set of A operators that form Klein’s 4-group: parity, time-reversal, parity&time-reversal, and unity. The link between symmetry and conservation laws is discussed and shown to be richer and subtler for non-Hermitian than for Hermitian Hamiltonians.