Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0709.2802

The importance of probability interference in social science: rationale and experiment

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov, Emmanuel E. Haven

Published Sep 18, 2007• 15 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Probability interference is a fundamental characteristic of quantum mechanics. In this paper we attempt to show with the help of some examples, where this fundamental trait of quantum physics can be found back in a social science environment. In order to support our thesis that interference can possibly be found back in many other macro-scopic areas, we proceed in setting up an experimental test.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.0709.2802

Related papers

On the notion of a macroscopic quantum system

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

It is proposed to define "quantumness" of a system (micro or macroscopic, physical, biological, social, political) by starting with understanding that quantum mechanics is a statistical theory. It says us only about probability distributions. The only possible criteria of quantum behaviour are statistical ones. Therefore I propose to consider any system which produces quantum statistics as quantum ("quantumlike"). A possible test is based on the interference of probabilities. I was mainly interested in using such an approach to "quantumness" to extend the domain of applications of quantum mathematical formalism and especially to apply it to cognitive sciences. There were done experiments on interference of probabilities for ensembles of students and a nontrivial interference was really found. One could say that the quantum statistical behaviour might be expected. But the problem was not so trivial. Yes, we might expect nonclassical statistics, but there was no reason to get the quantum one, i.e., cos-interference. But we got it!

arXiv:quant-ph/0408164•Aug 26, 2004•0 citations

On the cognitive experiments to test quantum-like behaviour of mind

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We describe cognitive experiments (based on interference of probabilities for mental observables) that could verify quantum-like structure of mental measurements. In principle, such experiments could be performed in psychology, cognitive and social sciences.

•May 15, 2002•10 citations

Quantum Probability Theory and Social Behavior Modeling: From Axioms to Applications

CHANGKUI LI

Quantum probability theory, originally developed in the context of quantum mechanics, has increasingly been applied to social sciences to explain decision-making, cognition, and collective behavior. Unlike classical probability models, which assume pre-existing and well-defined preferences, quantum models incorporate superposition, interference, and non-commutativity to capture the contextual dependence and measurement effects observed in human decisions. This paper systematically explores the theoretical foundations of quantum probability in social sciences, discusses model construction techniques, and reviews empirical findings supporting its application. By examining case studies in quantum cognition, quantum game theory, and quantum voting, we illustrate how quantum approaches provide alternative explanations for phenomena such as order effects, measurement-induced attitude shifts, and collective polarization. The paper also discusses the methodological challenges and limitations of quantum social science, emphasizing the need for rigorous experimental validation and interdisciplinary collaboration. Finally, we highlight the potential for integrating quantum probability models with emerging technologies such as quantum computing and artificial intelligence, opening new avenues for social science research and policy applications.

Quantum Social Science•Feb 18, 2025•1 citation

QUANTUM THEORY AND THE SOCIAL SCIENCES

Carlos Eduardo Maldonado

There is a solid growth of quantum theory in that there is quantum physics, quantum chemistry, quantum biology, and a robust technology based on quantum behaviors and effects - to name but the most solid examples of the development and enhancement of quantum science. Quantum science is by and large the most robust theory, ever. However, to date there is a gap between quantum physics and the social sciences, for very little has been said about their interplay. This paper discusses the importance of a relationship between quantum science and the social sciences, and the entailment of such a relation. It offers a brief state-of-the-art, and discusses the very significance of quantum social science.

MOMENTO•Oct 27, 2019•9 citations

Does Probability Interference Exist In Social Science?

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov, Emmanuel E. Haven

In this paper we discuss the rationale why sub(super)‐additive probabilities in a psychological setting could be explained via the use of quantum probability interference. We propose to measure the complementarity of two variables: i) time of processing (by experiment participants) of (non‐moving) images and ii) the ability (by experiment participants) of recognizing deformations of (non‐moving) pictures. We argue in the paper why we can not find this complementarity using the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle. The paper provides for the details on the experimental set up to test the complementarity.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2007•14 citations

The Topology of Quantum Theory and Social Choice

Graciela Chichilnisky

Based on the axioms of quantum theory, we identify a class of topological singularities that encode a fundamental difference between classic and quantum probability, and explain quantum theory’s puzzles and phenomena in simple mathematical terms so they are no longer ‘quantum paradoxes’. The singularities provide also new experimental insights and predictions that are presented in this article and establish a surprising new connection between the physical and social sciences. The key is the topology of spaces of quantum events and of the frameworks postulated by these axioms. These are quite different from their counterparts in classic probability and explain mathematically the interference between quantum experiments and the existence of several frameworks or ‘violation of unicity’ that characterizes quantum physics. They also explain entanglement, the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, order dependence of observations, the conjunction fallacy and geometric phenomena such as Pancharatnam–Berry phases. Somewhat surprisingly, we find that the same topological singularities explain the impossibility of selecting a social preference among different individual preferences: which is Arrow’s social choice paradox: the foundations of social choice and of quantum theory are therefore mathematically equivalent. We identify necessary and sufficient conditions on how to restrict experiments to avoid these singularities and recover unicity, avoiding possible interference between experiments and also quantum paradoxes; the same topological restriction is shown to provide a resolution to the social choice impossibility theorem of Chichilnisky.

Quantum Reports•Jun 16, 2022•5 citations
Probability interference is a fundamental characteristic of quantum mechanics. In this paper we attempt to show with the help of some examples, where this fundamental trait of quantum physics can be found back in a social science environment. In order to support our thesis that interference can possibly be found back in many other macro-scopic areas, we proceed in setting up an experimental test.
It is proposed to define "quantumness" of a system (micro or macroscopic, physical, biological, social, political) by starting with understanding that quantum mechanics is a statistical theory. It says us only about probability distributions. The only possible criteria of quantum behaviour are statistical ones. Therefore I propose to consider any system which produces quantum statistics as quantum ("quantumlike"). A possible test is based on the interference of probabilities. I was mainly interested in using such an approach to "quantumness" to extend the domain of applications of quantum mathematical formalism and especially to apply it to cognitive sciences. There were done experiments on interference of probabilities for ensembles of students and a nontrivial interference was really found. One could say that the quantum statistical behaviour might be expected. But the problem was not so trivial. Yes, we might expect nonclassical statistics, but there was no reason to get the quantum one, i.e., cos-interference. But we got it!
Quantum probability theory, originally developed in the context of quantum mechanics, has increasingly been applied to social sciences to explain decision-making, cognition, and collective behavior. Unlike classical probability models, which assume pre-existing and well-defined preferences, quantum models incorporate superposition, interference, and non-commutativity to capture the contextual dependence and measurement effects observed in human decisions. This paper systematically explores the theoretical foundations of quantum probability in social sciences, discusses model construction techniques, and reviews empirical findings supporting its application. By examining case studies in quantum cognition, quantum game theory, and quantum voting, we illustrate how quantum approaches provide alternative explanations for phenomena such as order effects, measurement-induced attitude shifts, and collective polarization. The paper also discusses the methodological challenges and limitations of quantum social science, emphasizing the need for rigorous experimental validation and interdisciplinary collaboration. Finally, we highlight the potential for integrating quantum probability models with emerging technologies such as quantum computing and artificial intelligence, opening new avenues for social science research and policy applications.
There is a solid growth of quantum theory in that there is quantum physics, quantum chemistry, quantum biology, and a robust technology based on quantum behaviors and effects - to name but the most solid examples of the development and enhancement of quantum science. Quantum science is by and large the most robust theory, ever. However, to date there is a gap between quantum physics and the social sciences, for very little has been said about their interplay. This paper discusses the importance of a relationship between quantum science and the social sciences, and the entailment of such a relation. It offers a brief state-of-the-art, and discusses the very significance of quantum social science.
In this paper we discuss the rationale why sub(super)‐additive probabilities in a psychological setting could be explained via the use of quantum probability interference. We propose to measure the complementarity of two variables: i) time of processing (by experiment participants) of (non‐moving) images and ii) the ability (by experiment participants) of recognizing deformations of (non‐moving) pictures. We argue in the paper why we can not find this complementarity using the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle. The paper provides for the details on the experimental set up to test the complementarity.
Based on the axioms of quantum theory, we identify a class of topological singularities that encode a fundamental difference between classic and quantum probability, and explain quantum theory’s puzzles and phenomena in simple mathematical terms so they are no longer ‘quantum paradoxes’. The singularities provide also new experimental insights and predictions that are presented in this article and establish a surprising new connection between the physical and social sciences. The key is the topology of spaces of quantum events and of the frameworks postulated by these axioms. These are quite different from their counterparts in classic probability and explain mathematically the interference between quantum experiments and the existence of several frameworks or ‘violation of unicity’ that characterizes quantum physics. They also explain entanglement, the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, order dependence of observations, the conjunction fallacy and geometric phenomena such as Pancharatnam–Berry phases. Somewhat surprisingly, we find that the same topological singularities explain the impossibility of selecting a social preference among different individual preferences: which is Arrow’s social choice paradox: the foundations of social choice and of quantum theory are therefore mathematically equivalent. We identify necessary and sufficient conditions on how to restrict experiments to avoid these singularities and recover unicity, avoiding possible interference between experiments and also quantum paradoxes; the same topological restriction is shown to provide a resolution to the social choice impossibility theorem of Chichilnisky.