In arXiv:0709.0483 Gunther and Samsonov outline a ``generalization'' of quantum mechanics that involves simultaneous consideration of Hermitian and non-Hermitian operators and promises to be ``capable to produce effects beyond those of standard Hermitian quantum mechanics.'' We give a simple physical interpretation of Hermiticity and discuss in detail the shortcomings of the above-mentioned composite quantum theory. In particular, we show that the corresponding ``generalization of measurement theory'' suffers from a dynamical inconsistency and that it is by no means adequate to replace the standard measurement theory.
In arXiv:0709.0483 Gunther and Samsonov outline a generalization'' of quantum mechanics that involves simultaneous consideration of Hermitian and non-Hermitian operators and promises to be capable to produce effects beyond those of standard Hermitian quantum mechanics.'' We give a simple physical interpretation of Hermiticity and discuss in detail the shortcomings of the above-mentioned composite quantum theory. In particular, we show that the corresponding ``generalization of measurement theory'' suffers from a dynamical inconsistency and that it is by no means adequate to replace the standard measurement theory.
In most introductory courses on quantum mechanics one is taught that the Hamiltonian operator must be Hermitian in order that the energy levels be real and that the theory be unitary (probability conserving). To express the Hermiticity of a Hamiltonian, one writes H = H †, where the symbol † denotes the usual Dirac Hermitian conjugation; that is, transpose and complex conjugate. In the past few years it has been recognized that the requirement of Hermiticity, which is often stated as an axiom of quantum mechanics, may be replaced by the less mathematical and more physical requirement of space – time reflection symmetry (𝒫𝒯 symmetry) without losing any of the essential physical features of quantum mechanics. Theories defined by non-Hermitian 𝒫𝒯-symmetric Hamiltonians exhibit strange and unexpected properties at the classical as well as at the quantum level. This paper explains how the requirement of Hermiticity can be evaded and discusses the properties of some non-Hermitian 𝒫𝒯-symmetric quantum theories.
Abstract PT-symmetric quantum theory was originally proposed with the aim of extending standard quantum theory by relaxing the Hermiticity constraint on Hamiltonians. However, no such extension has been formulated that consistently describes states, transformations, measurements and composition, which is a requirement for any physical theory. We aim to answer the question of whether a consistent physical theory with PT-symmetric observables extends standard quantum theory. We answer this question within the framework of general probabilistic theories, which is the most general framework for physical theories. We construct the set of states of a system that result from imposing PT-symmetry on the set of observables, and show that the resulting theory allows only one trivial state. We next consider the constraint of quasi-Hermiticity on observables, which guarantees the unitarity of evolution under a Hamiltonian with unbroken PT-symmetry. We show that such a system is equivalent to a standard quantum system. Finally, we show that if all observables are quasi-Hermitian as well as PT-symmetric, then the system is equivalent to a real quantum system. Thus our results show that neither PT-symmetry nor quasi-Hermiticity constraints are sufficient to extend standard quantum theory consistently.
In the framework of quasi-Hermitian quantum mechanics, the eligible operators of observables may be non-Hermitian, Aj≠Aj†, j=1,2,…,K. In principle, the standard probabilistic interpretation of the theory can be re-established via a reconstruction of physical inner-product metric Θ≠I, guaranteeing the quasi-Hermiticity Aj†Θ=ΘAj. The task is easy at K=1 because there are many eligible metrics Θ=Θ(A1). In our paper, the next case with K=2 is analyzed. The criteria of the existence of a shared metric, Θ=Θ(A1,A2), are presented and discussed.
Abstract In Alase et al (2022 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 55 244003), Alase et al wrote that ‘the constraint of quasi-Hermiticity on observables’ is not ‘sufficient to extend the standard quantum theory’ because ‘such a system is equivalent to a standard quantum system.’ Three addenda elucidating the current state of the art are found necessary. The first one concerns the project: in the related literature the original ‘aim of extending standard quantum theory’ has already been abandoned shortly after its formulation. The second comment concerns the method, viz., the study in ‘the framework of general probabilistic theories’ (GPT). It is noticed that a few other, mathematically consistent GPT-like theories are available. The authors do not mention, in particular, the progress achieved, under the quasi-Hermiticity constraint, in the approach using the effect algebras. We add that this approach already found its advanced realistic applications in the quasi-Hermitian models using the unbounded operators of observables acting in the infinite-dimensional Hilbert spaces. Thirdly, the ‘intriguing open question’ about ‘what possible constraints, if any, could lead to such a meaningful extension’ (in the future) is given an immediate tentative answer: the possibility is advocated that the desirable constraint could really be just the quasi-Hermiticity of the observables, provided only that one has in mind its recently developed non-stationary version.
Hermiticity of the Hamiltonian is a foundational assumption of standard quantum mechanics, guaranteeing real eigenvalues, unitary evolution, and a consistent probability interpretation. We argue that this assumption, while epistemically indispensable in the low-energy limit, may not be ontologically fundamental. Working within the Quantum Reality Framework (QRF), in which physical structure is derived from a causal set (E, ≺, A), we propose to identify the relational amplitude kernel A(x,y) with the Benincasa–Dowker operator and suggest a route toward recovering aspects of the kinematical structure of quantum theory — Hilbert space, dispersion relation, and momentum operator — in the continuum limit. A fundamental tension then arises: the BD kernel is intrinsically time-directed and non-symmetric, while quantum mechanics requires a Hermitian kernel. We propose that Hermiticity is an emergent approximate symmetry valid in the limit E ≪ E_P, and that the appropriate mathematical framework is pseudo-Hermitian quantum mechanics (Bender & Boettcher 1998; Mostafazadeh 2002). This leads to potentially falsifiable consequences, partly model-dependent in their precise form: a qubit/qutrit decoherence ratio τ(qubit)/τ(qutrit) = 3/5 in a minimal implementation, quadratic Lorentz invariance violation δv/v ∼ −(E/E_P)²/6, mass-dependent deviations in matter-wave interference, and possible CPT violation at order (m/m_P)². Keywords: causal sets · quantum foundations · Hermiticity · PT-symmetry · time asymmetry · emergent quantum mechanics