Upon reviewing the article by Allahverdyan and Nieuwenhuizen in PRE, we conclude that neither the Landauer principle nor the counterexamples presented by the authors have any relation (i) to thermodynamics, and (ii) to the interdependence of nonstatistical quantum physics and thermodynamics.
This article discusses the concept of information and its intimate relationship with physics. After an introduction of all the necessary quantum mechanical and information theoretical concepts we analyse Landauer's principle which states that the erasure of information is inevitably accompanied by the generation of heat. We employ this principle to rederive a number of results in classical and quantum information theory whose rigorous mathematical derivations are difficult. This demonstrates the usefulness of Landauer's principle and provides an introduction to the physical theory of information.
Landauer's principle provides a fundamental lower bound for energy dissipation occurring with information erasure in the quantum regime. While most studies have related the entropy reduction incorporated with the erasure to the lower bound (entropic bound), recent efforts have also provided another lower bound associated with the thermal fluctuation of the dissipated energy (thermodynamic bound). The coexistence of the two bounds has stimulated comparative studies of their properties; however, these studies were performed for systems where the time-evolution of diagonal (population) and off-diagonal (coherence) elements of the density matrix are decoupled. In this paper, we aimed to broaden the comparative study to include the influence of quantum coherence induced by the tilted system-reservoir interaction direction. By examining their dependence on the initial state of the information-bearing system, we find that the following properties of the bounds are generically held regardless of whether the influence of the coherence is present or not: the entropic bound serves as the tighter bound for a sufficiently mixed initial state, while the thermodynamic bound is tighter when the purity of the initial state is sufficiently high. The exception is the case where the system dynamics involve only phase relaxation; in this case, the two bounds coincide when the initial coherence is zero; otherwise, the thermodynamic bound serves the tighter bound. We also find the quantum information erasure inevitably accompanies constant energy dissipation caused by the creation of system-reservoir correlation, which may cause an additional source of energetic cost for the erasure.
The natural framework to discuss thermodynamics at the quantum level is the theory of open quantum systems. Memory effects arising from strong system-environment correlations may lead to information back-flow, that is non-Markovian behaviour. The relation between non-Markovianity and quantum thermodynamics has been until now largely unexplored. Here we show by means of Landauer's principle that memory effects control the amount of work extraction by erasure in presence of realistic environments.
A known aspect of the Clausius inequality is that an equilibrium system subjected to a squeezing dS < 0 of its entropy must release at least an amount the absolute value of dQ = T times the absolute value of dS of heat. This serves as a basis for the Landauer principle, which puts a lower bound T ln 2 for the heat generated by erasure of one bit of information. Here we show that in the world of quantum entanglement this law is broken. A quantum Brownian particle interacting with its thermal bath can either generate less heat or even absorb heat during an analogous squeezing process, due to entanglement with the bath. The effect exists even for weak but fixed coupling with the bath, provided that temperature is low enough. This invalidates the Landauer bound in the quantum regime, and suggests that quantum carriers of information can be more efficient than assumed so far.
The dynamical role of system-environment correlations will lead to the violation of Landauer's principle and may result in a non-Markovian dynamics of the system. Here, we employ entropic quantities called the telescopic relative entropy, to detect non-Markovianity [N. Megier, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 030401 (2021)], and study the relation between information backflow of non-Markovian dynamics and the validity of Landauer's principle. We consider a class of energy-conserving system-environment interactions in qubit systems, and we prove that the violation of Landauer's principle corresponds to information backflow of a thermalizing process without coherence and vice versa. Then we study the effect of quantum coherence of the system on the relationship between non-Markovianity and Landauer's principle, and we find that coherence will break the corresponding relation in the information backflow and violation of Landauer's principle. Based on this, we explain the physical mechanism of non-Markovianity in this irreversible process of heat dissipation and information erasure. We further numerically confirm the above theoretical results by means of a collision model.