Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0705.1477 · American Journal of Physics

Quantum entanglement, fair sampling, and reality: Is the moon there when nobody looks?

Guillaume Adenier

Published Jan 12, 2008• 11 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In 1981 Mermin described a clever and simplified version of Bell’s theorem. He pointed out in a straightforward way that interpreting entanglement from a local realist point of view could be problematic. I propose an extended version of Mermin’s device that can be given a simple local realist interpretation by a sample selection bias. I argue that we still have no scientific reason to believe that the moon could not be there when nobody looks.

DOI
10.1119/1.2825326

Related papers

Is the Moon There If Nobody Looks: Bell Inequalities and Physical Reality

Marian Kupczyński

Bell-CHSH inequalities are trivial algebraic properties satisfied by each line of Nx4 spreadsheets containing ±1 entries, thus it is surprising that their violation in some experiments allows to speculate about the existence of nonlocal influences in nature and casts doubt on the existence of external physical reality. Such speculations are rooted in incorrect interpretations of quantum mechanics and in a failure of local realistic hidden variable models to reproduce quantum predictions for spin polarisation correlation experiments (SPCE). In these models, one uses a counterfactual joint probability distribution of only pairwise measurable random variables (A, A’, B, B’) to prove Bell-CHSH inequalities. In SPCE Alice and Bob, using 4 incompatible pairs of experimental settings, estimate imperfect correlations between clicks registered by their detectors. Clicks announce detection of photons and are coded by ±1. Expectations of corresponding random variables: E (AB), E (AB’), E (A’B) and E (A’B’) are estimated and compared with quantum predictions. These estimates significantly violate CHSH inequalities. Since variables (A, A’) as well as (B, B’) cannot be measured jointly, neither Nx4 spreadsheets nor a joint probability distribution of (A, A’, B, B’) exist, thus Bell-CHSH inequalities may not be derived. Nevertheless, imperfect correlations between clicks in SPCE may be explained in a locally causal way, if contextual setting-dependent parameters describing measuring instruments are correctly included in the description. The violation of Bell-CHSH inequalities may not therefore justify the existence of a spooky action at the distance, super-determinism or speculations that an electron can be here and a meter away at the same time. In this paper we review and rephrase several arguments proving that such conclusions are unfounded. Entangled photon pairs cannot be described as pairs of socks nor as pairs of fair dice producing in each trial perfectly correlated outcomes. Thus the violation of inequalities confirms only that the measurement outcomes and `the fate of photons ` are not predetermined before the experiment is done. It does not allow for doubt regarding the objective existence of atoms, electrons and other invisible elementary particles which are the building blocks of the visible world around us including ourselves.

arXiv:2004.14570•Frontiers in Physics•Sep 23, 2020•55 citations

If the Moon Really Is Not there when Nobody Looks

Hongfang Li

The essence of the debate of philosophy about Weather is not the moon there when nobody looks?, involve the objective reality of micro-particles during quantum measure. However, the development of quantum mechanics don't deny the objective reality of micro-particles before observed, and only demonstrate micro-particles be of wave-particle duality. What to by the name of quantum mechanics, steal the concept of idealism, in front of the practice of science, be doomed to fail.

齐鲁学刊•Jan 1, 2004•0 citations

Einstein's Moon

Daegene Song

An account of the subjective elements of quantum mechanics or of whether, as Einstein famously asked, the Moon exists when nobody is looking at it.

Physics-Uspekhi•Jan 1, 2012•2 citations

Further comments on ‘Is the moon there if nobody looks? Bell inequalities and physical reality’

Richard David Gill

Kupczynski (2023) claims that Gill and Lambare (2022a, 2022b) misrepresent several of his published papers. This paper shows that the latest version of his “contextuality by default” model of a Bell experiment places no constraints whatsoever on the statistics of observed results in such experiments. It thereby effectively allows arbitrary non-locality, ie direct causal effects of local measurement settings on distant measurement outcomes.

arXiv:2305.03026•May 5, 2023•3 citations

Is the Moon There When Nobody Looks? Reality and the Quantum Theory

N. David Mermin

In May 1935, Albert Einstein, Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen published an argument that quantum mechanics fails to provide a complete description of physical reality. Today, 50 years later, the EPR paper and the theoretical and experimental work it inspired remain remarkable for the vivid illustration they provide of one of the most bizarre aspects of the world revealed to us by the quantum theory.

Physics Today•Apr 1, 1985•584 citations

Is the Moon there if nobody looks: A reply to Gill and Lambare

Marian Kupczyński

In a recent preprint Gill and Lambare, criticize our paper published in Frontiers in Physics. Their criticism is unfounded and misleading. They define a probabilistic coupling, in which BI-CHSH hold for all finite samples. It does not mean, that BI-CHSH hold in our model, in which four incompatible experiments are described by setting dependent random variables implemented on 4 disjoint dedicated probability spaces. A joint probability distribution of these random variables does not exist and may not be used to derive inequalities. Moreover, their probabilistic coupling is useless, for a subsequent contextual model, which we construct to describe final data from Bell tests and to explain, in a locally causal way, the reported violations of inequalities and apparent violations of no-signaling. Neither quantum probabilistic model of an ideal EPRB experiment nor local realistic and stochastic hidden variable models may explain reported non-signaling Therefore; it is obvious that our model extends the set of probability distributions of possible measurements allowed in the standard hidden variable models. Gill and Lambare seem not understand , the main message of our paper, that the violation of BI-CHSH and Eberhard inequalities by finite samples in Bell Tests, no matter how well these tests are designed and performed, does not allow for doubt regarding the existence of objective external physical reality and causal locality in Nature. Our contextual model does not want to circumvent Bell Theorem. Therefore the title of Gill and Lambare paper and the conclusion: Kupczynski's escape route for local realism is not available are misleading and have nothing to do with the content and conclusions of our paper.

arXiv:2209.07992•Sep 16, 2022•5 citations
In 1981 Mermin described a clever and simplified version of Bell’s theorem. He pointed out in a straightforward way that interpreting entanglement from a local realist point of view could be problematic. I propose an extended version of Mermin’s device that can be given a simple local realist interpretation by a sample selection bias. I argue that we still have no scientific reason to believe that the moon could not be there when nobody looks.
Bell-CHSH inequalities are trivial algebraic properties satisfied by each line of Nx4 spreadsheets containing ±1 entries, thus it is surprising that their violation in some experiments allows to speculate about the existence of nonlocal influences in nature and casts doubt on the existence of external physical reality. Such speculations are rooted in incorrect interpretations of quantum mechanics and in a failure of local realistic hidden variable models to reproduce quantum predictions for spin polarisation correlation experiments (SPCE). In these models, one uses a counterfactual joint probability distribution of only pairwise measurable random variables (A, A’, B, B’) to prove Bell-CHSH inequalities. In SPCE Alice and Bob, using 4 incompatible pairs of experimental settings, estimate imperfect correlations between clicks registered by their detectors. Clicks announce detection of photons and are coded by ±1. Expectations of corresponding random variables: E (AB), E (AB’), E (A’B) and E (A’B’) are estimated and compared with quantum predictions. These estimates significantly violate CHSH inequalities. Since variables (A, A’) as well as (B, B’) cannot be measured jointly, neither Nx4 spreadsheets nor a joint probability distribution of (A, A’, B, B’) exist, thus Bell-CHSH inequalities may not be derived. Nevertheless, imperfect correlations between clicks in SPCE may be explained in a locally causal way, if contextual setting-dependent parameters describing measuring instruments are correctly included in the description. The violation of Bell-CHSH inequalities may not therefore justify the existence of a spooky action at the distance, super-determinism or speculations that an electron can be here and a meter away at the same time. In this paper we review and rephrase several arguments proving that such conclusions are unfounded. Entangled photon pairs cannot be described as pairs of socks nor as pairs of fair dice producing in each trial perfectly correlated outcomes. Thus the violation of inequalities confirms only that the measurement outcomes and `the fate of photons ` are not predetermined before the experiment is done. It does not allow for doubt regarding the objective existence of atoms, electrons and other invisible elementary particles which are the building blocks of the visible world around us including ourselves.
In a recent preprint Gill and Lambare, criticize our paper published in Frontiers in Physics. Their criticism is unfounded and misleading. They define a probabilistic coupling, in which BI-CHSH hold for all finite samples. It does not mean, that BI-CHSH hold in our model, in which four incompatible experiments are described by setting dependent random variables implemented on 4 disjoint dedicated probability spaces. A joint probability distribution of these random variables does not exist and may not be used to derive inequalities. Moreover, their probabilistic coupling is useless, for a subsequent contextual model, which we construct to describe final data from Bell tests and to explain, in a locally causal way, the reported violations of inequalities and apparent violations of no-signaling. Neither quantum probabilistic model of an ideal EPRB experiment nor local realistic and stochastic hidden variable models may explain reported non-signaling Therefore; it is obvious that our model extends the set of probability distributions of possible measurements allowed in the standard hidden variable models. Gill and Lambare seem not understand , the main message of our paper, that the violation of BI-CHSH and Eberhard inequalities by finite samples in Bell Tests, no matter how well these tests are designed and performed, does not allow for doubt regarding the existence of objective external physical reality and causal locality in Nature. Our contextual model does not want to circumvent Bell Theorem. Therefore the title of Gill and Lambare paper and the conclusion: Kupczynski's escape route for local realism is not available are misleading and have nothing to do with the content and conclusions of our paper.