Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0704.2961 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

On maximal entanglement between two pairs in four-qubit pure states

Shirley Brierley, Atsushi Higuchi

Published Jul 3, 2007• 51 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We show that the state with the highest known average two-particle von Neumann entanglement entropy proposed by Sudbery and one of the authors gives a local maximum of this entropy. We also show that this is not the case for an alternative highly entangled state proposed by Brown et al .
DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/40/29/018

Related papers

The most entangled states of four and seven qubits

Antony Lewis

Pure states of four and seven qubits cannot be maximally entangled across every balanced bipartition; we determine how entangled they can be on average. For four qubits we prove the conjecture of Higuchi and Sudbery: the mean von Neumann entropy of the three $2|2$ cuts is at most $1+\tfrac12\log_2 3$ bits, with equality exactly on the local-unitary orbits of their state $M_4$ and its complex conjugate. For seven qubits the mean purity of the 35 balanced $3|4$ cuts is at least $121/917$ and their mean entropy is at most $2.965356029\ldots$ bits, each with a unique optimiser up to local unitaries and qubit permutations. The two optimisers are distinct members of one icosahedral family, so minimum purity and maximum entropy select different states. The proofs bound moments of the marginal spectra by positive identities on several copies of the state, some of them spin flipped, and bound the entropy by a polynomial in those moments. The four-qubit maximum has an analytic proof; the seven-qubit proofs, and some of the four-qubit refinements below, are computer-assisted, with exact arithmetic and rigorous error bounds. We also prove the Gour--Wallach conjecture for Rényi entropies of all orders, with the maximiser changing from $M_4$ to cluster states at $q_*\approx1.588$, and obtain sharp Tsallis bounds, mixed-state bounds and quantitative stability.

arXiv:2611.05757•Nov 3, 2026•0 citations

All maximally entangled four-qubit states

Gilad Gour, Nolan R. Wallach

We find an operational interpretation for the 4-tangle as a type of residual entanglement, somewhat similar to the interpretation of the 3-tangle. Using this remarkable interpretation, we are able to find the class of maximally entangled four-qubits states which is characterized by four real parameters. The states in the class are maximally entangled in the sense that their average bipartite entanglement with respect to all possible bipartite cuts is maximal. We show that while all the states in the class maximize the average tangle, there are only a few states in the class that maximize the average Tsillas or Renyi α-entropy of entanglement. Quite remarkably, we find that up to local unitaries, there exists two unique states, one maximizing the average α-Tsallis entropy of entanglement for all α ⩾ 2, while the other maximizing it for all 0 < α ⩽ 2 (including the von-Neumann case of α = 1). Furthermore, among the maximally entangled four qubits states, there are only three maximally entangled states that have the property that for two, out of the three bipartite cuts consisting of two-qubits verses two-qubits, the entanglement is 2 ebits and for the remaining bipartite cut the entanglement between the two groups of two qubits is 1 ebit. The unique three maximally entangled states are the three cluster states that are related by a swap operator. We also show that the cluster states are the only states (up to local unitaries) that maximize the average α-Renyi entropy of entanglement for all α ⩾ 2.

arXiv:1006.0036•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Nov 1, 2010•149 citations

Bell’s inequality and entanglement in qubits

Po-Yao Chang, Su-Kuan Chu, Chen‐Te Ma

We propose an alternative evaluation of quantum entanglement by measuring the maximum violation of the Bell’s inequality without information of the reduced density matrix of a system. This proposal is demonstrated by bridging the maximum violation of the Bell’s inequality and a concurrence of a pure state in an n-qubit system, in which one subsystem only contains one qubit and the state is a linear combination of two product states. We apply this relation to the ground states of four qubits in the Wen-Plaquette model and show that they are maximally entangled. A topological entanglement entropy of the Wen-Plaquette model could be obtained by relating the upper bound of the maximum violation of the Bell’s inequality to the generalized concurrence of a pure state with respect to different bipartitions.

arXiv:1705.06444•Journal of High Energy Physics•Sep 1, 2017•10 citations

On two maximally entangled couples

Felix Huber, Jens Siewert

Abstract In a seminal article, Higuchi and Sudbery showed that a pure four-qubit state cannot be maximally entangled across every bipartition. Such states are now known as absolutely maximally entangled (AME) states. Here we give a series of old and new proofs of the fact that no four-qubit AME state exists. These are based on invariant theory, methods from coding theory, and basic properties from linear algebra such as the Pauli commutation relations.

arXiv:2506.21282•Quantum Science and Technology•Nov 25, 2025•4 citations

A Comparison of the Entanglement Measures for Multipartite Pure States

Cao Wan-Cang, Dan Liu, Bai Hong-bo

In this paper,a concise and alternative average entropy is introduced,which can be used to analyze entanglement of multipartite pure states.By comparing with the average von Neumann entropy established previously,the results show that the entanglement of multipartite pure states can also be measured in this new scheme.

Journal of Liaoning Normal University•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations

Extremal maximal entanglement

Wanchen Zhang, Yu Ning, Fei Shi +1 more

A pure multipartite quantum state is called absolutely maximally entangled if all reductions of no more than half of the parties are maximally mixed. However, an $n$-qubit absolutely maximally entangled state exists only when $n$ equals 2, 3, 5, and 6. A natural question arises when it does not exist: Which $n$-qubit pure state has the largest number of maximally mixed $\ensuremath{\lfloor}n/2\ensuremath{\rfloor}$-party reductions? We denote this number by $\mathrm{Qex}(n)$. It was shown that $\mathrm{Qex}(4)=4$ by Higuchi and Sudbery [Phys. Lett. A 273, 213 (2000)] and $\mathrm{Qex}(7)=32$ by Huber et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 200502 (2017)]. In this paper, we give a general upper bound of $\mathrm{Qex}(n)$ by linking the well-known Tur\'an problem in graph theory and provide lower bounds using constructive and probabilistic methods. In particular, we show that $\mathrm{Qex}(8)=56$, which is the third known value for this problem.

arXiv:2411.12208•Physical Review A•May 7, 2025•5 citations
Pure states of four and seven qubits cannot be maximally entangled across every balanced bipartition; we determine how entangled they can be on average. For four qubits we prove the conjecture of Higuchi and Sudbery: the mean von Neumann entropy of the three 2∣22|22∣2 cuts is at most 1+12log⁡231+\tfrac12\log_2 31+21​log2​3 bits, with equality exactly on the local-unitary orbits of their state M4M_4M4​ and its complex conjugate. For seven qubits the mean purity of the 35 balanced 3∣43|43∣4 cuts is at least 121/917121/917121/917 and their mean entropy is at most 2.965356029…2.965356029\ldots2.965356029… bits, each with a unique optimiser up to local unitaries and qubit permutations. The two optimisers are distinct members of one icosahedral family, so minimum purity and maximum entropy select different states. The proofs bound moments of the marginal spectra by positive identities on several copies of the state, some of them spin flipped, and bound the entropy by a polynomial in those moments. The four-qubit maximum has an analytic proof; the seven-qubit proofs, and some of the four-qubit refinements below, are computer-assisted, with exact arithmetic and rigorous error bounds. We also prove the Gour--Wallach conjecture for Rényi entropies of all orders, with the maximiser changing from M4M_4M4​ to cluster states at q∗≈1.588q_*\approx1.588q∗​≈1.588, and obtain sharp Tsallis bounds, mixed-state bounds and quantitative stability.
We find an operational interpretation for the 4-tangle as a type of residual entanglement, somewhat similar to the interpretation of the 3-tangle. Using this remarkable interpretation, we are able to find the class of maximally entangled four-qubits states which is characterized by four real parameters. The states in the class are maximally entangled in the sense that their average bipartite entanglement with respect to all possible bipartite cuts is maximal. We show that while all the states in the class maximize the average tangle, there are only a few states in the class that maximize the average Tsillas or Renyi α-entropy of entanglement. Quite remarkably, we find that up to local unitaries, there exists two unique states, one maximizing the average α-Tsallis entropy of entanglement for all α ⩾ 2, while the other maximizing it for all 0 < α ⩽ 2 (including the von-Neumann case of α = 1). Furthermore, among the maximally entangled four qubits states, there are only three maximally entangled states that have the property that for two, out of the three bipartite cuts consisting of two-qubits verses two-qubits, the entanglement is 2 ebits and for the remaining bipartite cut the entanglement between the two groups of two qubits is 1 ebit. The unique three maximally entangled states are the three cluster states that are related by a swap operator. We also show that the cluster states are the only states (up to local unitaries) that maximize the average α-Renyi entropy of entanglement for all α ⩾ 2.
We propose an alternative evaluation of quantum entanglement by measuring the maximum violation of the Bell’s inequality without information of the reduced density matrix of a system. This proposal is demonstrated by bridging the maximum violation of the Bell’s inequality and a concurrence of a pure state in an n-qubit system, in which one subsystem only contains one qubit and the state is a linear combination of two product states. We apply this relation to the ground states of four qubits in the Wen-Plaquette model and show that they are maximally entangled. A topological entanglement entropy of the Wen-Plaquette model could be obtained by relating the upper bound of the maximum violation of the Bell’s inequality to the generalized concurrence of a pure state with respect to different bipartitions.
A pure multipartite quantum state is called absolutely maximally entangled if all reductions of no more than half of the parties are maximally mixed. However, an nnn-qubit absolutely maximally entangled state exists only when nnn equals 2, 3, 5, and 6. A natural question arises when it does not exist: Which nnn-qubit pure state has the largest number of maximally mixed $\ensuremath{\lfloor}n/2\ensuremath{\rfloor}$-party reductions? We denote this number by Qex(n)\mathrm{Qex}(n)Qex(n). It was shown that Qex(4)=4\mathrm{Qex}(4)=4Qex(4)=4 by Higuchi and Sudbery [Phys. Lett. A 273, 213 (2000)] and Qex(7)=32\mathrm{Qex}(7)=32Qex(7)=32 by Huber et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 200502 (2017)]. In this paper, we give a general upper bound of Qex(n)\mathrm{Qex}(n)Qex(n) by linking the well-known Tur\'an problem in graph theory and provide lower bounds using constructive and probabilistic methods. In particular, we show that Qex(8)=56\mathrm{Qex}(8)=56Qex(8)=56, which is the third known value for this problem.